A New Approach

[Caroline]

She couldn't. She wanted to go and see them as she felt "she had to see the bodies, and she specifically asked DS Jones if she could.

No she didn't - she offered when Colin and Jeremy refused - If you have proof that she asked, then post it!

[Kaldin]

No she didn't - she offered when Colin and Jeremy refused - If you have proof that she asked, then post it!

Here you are. She asked DS Jones and the arrangements were made.

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,1932

[Adam]

Here you are. She asked DS Jones and the arrangements were made.

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,1932

That just says she did it. Not that she was asked or offerred.

[Kaldin]

That just says she did it. Not that she was asked or offerred.

It says that she requested to see the bodies.

[Kaldin]

In fact, she thought about requesting to see them a second time, but she thought that might look suspicious and that questions would be asked.

[Caroline]

It says that she requested to see the bodies.

Where does it state that she requested to see them?

[Kaldin]

Where does it state that she requested to see them?

Page 7/8 of her statement dated 10th September.

[Adam]

'At.....I attended the mortuary where I viewed the bodies'.

Still can't see the word requested.

But if she did offer to help Bamber, the police & the relatives, so what ?

[Kaldin]

'At.....I attended the mortuary where I viewed the bodies'.

Still can't see the word requested.

But if she did offer to help Bamber, the police & the relatives, so what ?

Try reading the correct bit.

So what? So she wanted to see the bodies of the people she allegedly knew Jeremy had murdered. Do you not find that bizarre?

[Adam]

Try reading the correct bit.

So what? So she wanted to see the bodies of the people she allegedly knew Jeremy had murdered. Do you not find that bizarre?

Who said she wanted to ?  She never asked to be at WHF in the first place. Bamber whisking her over after his third call to her.

She identified the bodies to try to be helpful as she could identify them apart. As well as several other reasons I have given a list of.

[Caroline]

Try reading the correct bit.

So what? So she wanted to see the bodies of the people she allegedly knew Jeremy had murdered. Do you not find that bizarre?

Fair enough, it does state that, but if you read all of the documents concerning ID'ing the bodies. Colin was asked first and refused, Jeremy also refused so she didn't just request to ID  them off the cuff.

[Adam]

Try reading the correct bit.

So what? So she wanted to see the bodies of the people she allegedly knew Jeremy had murdered. Do you not find that bizarre?

I just read it again. It only mentions the visit in the last 4 lines. But does not say 'requested'.

[Kaldin]

Yes she did. She said she wanted to see if they'd suffered.

Look, even if she did to spare Jeremy, what was she thinking? Was she thinking - awww, the poor lamb has just had his family murdered and he's too upset to see them, so I'll do it to spare his feelings? I mean, what sort of person thinks that way?

[Adam]

Yes she did. She said she wanted to see if they'd suffered.

Look, even if she did to spare Jeremy, what was she thinking? Was she thinking - awww, the poor lamb has just had his family murdered and he's too upset to see them, so I'll do it to spare his feelings? I mean, what sort of person thinks that way?

Alright. You believe Julie shouldn't have identified the bodies. After Bamber had whisked her to WHF and just told her MM had committed the massacre.

Although there are several reasons why she did.

How does that negate the evidence that Bamber committed the massacre ?

[Kaldin]

Alright. You believe Julie shouldn't have identified the bodies. After Bamber had whisked her to WHF and just told her MM had committed the massacre.

Although there are several reasons why she did.

How does that negate the evidence that Bamber committed the massacre ?

Why do you think she should have done it?