Category A Prisoner

[lookout]

The one you said Sheila gave her??

Yes,I said that and I still believe that's what happened,but I don't remember seeing the bit where JB was quick to say it was Sheila.
I did think it was JM after June had called her a harlot.

[Caroline]

Good find!

I've mentioned this before Steph - I've never said June didn't have a black eye because I know fine well that she did.

[Jane]

Lookout, it's never a good idea to even HINT that Caroline might not be telling the truth

[Jane]

Yes,I said that and I still believe that's what happened,but I don't remember seeing the bit where JB was quick to say it was Sheila.
I did think it was JM after June had called her a harlot.

Yet your post said "What black eye?"..................Lookout, you're mixing times and dates. June called Julie "a harlot" when she first started staying at Jeremy's cottage some 18 months earlier.

[Caroline]

So June had a black eye and neither Jean B or Barbara W mentioned anything about it. They must have seen her during the day before the murders. The ONLY person who mentions seeing it when she was alive, is Jeremy.

[Steve_uk]

So June had a black eye and neither Jean B or Barbara W mentioned anything about it. They must have seen her during the day before the murders. The ONLY person who mentions seeing it when she was alive, is Jeremy.

So when is it presumed that June received the black eye, from whatever quarter it emanated?

[Caroline]

So when is it presumed that June received the black eye, from whatever quarter it emanated?

It isn't - that's what I am asking. No one mentioned it - only Jeremy. Someone would surely have mentioned it, IF they had seen it? Colin didn't mention it either and he saw her on the Sunday. She must have seen several people in between Sunday and Tuesday night - and no one mentions it??

[lookout]

Lookout, it's never a good idea to even HINT that Caroline might not be telling the truth

Likewise.

[Jane]

Likewise.

Let me re-phrase that, Lookout. It isn't a good idea to even HINT that Caroline might not have got her facts right.

[lookout]

Let me re-phrase that, Lookout. It isn't a good idea to even HINT that Caroline might not have got her facts right.

 Or ?

[Caroline]

Likewise.

Yesterday you called me a liar - today you said I posted that June didn't have a black eye. Both claims are bogus - It certainly is a good idea to tell you to get your facts right!

[Caroline]

 Or ?

You'll end up with even MORE egg on your face!

[lookout]

Yesterday you called me a liar - today you said I posted that June didn't have a black eye. Both claims are bogus - It certainly is a good idea to tell you to get your facts right!

It goes to prove how much I trust you does it not ? Though it wasn't how Jane put it----------that was more of a threat and I don't do threats.

[Caroline]

It goes to prove how much I trust you does it not ? Though it wasn't how Jane put it----------that was more of a threat and I don't do threats.

No, but it does prove the kind of person you really are.

[Jane]

It goes to prove how much I trust you does it not ? Though it wasn't how Jane put it----------that was more of a threat and I don't do threats.

Lookout, PLEASE stop being so defensive. There was no threat from me but you were so quick to turn it into one by asking "Or" that I feel I may have touched a nerve. You were also very quick to imply that it would be wrong of me to suggest that you might not be telling the truth, yet very clearly you often get your facts very wrong.