The bedroom phone, phone calls & Neville.

[Martin]

Don't type at me like that!

If you can't cope with having your theories challenged then perhaps this forum isn't the best place for you.
For the record, I happen to believe that Jeremy's conviction is hugely questionable.

If Ralf considered the situation to be serious enough, to call Jeremy and ask him to come over and help, then I can't believe that he hadn't first of all, forcibly tried to disarm her.

If you think that it would be a good idea to try to forcibly disarm a person with a loaded weapon experiencing a psychotic episode then you are not thinking straight.

[nugnug]

well there was nobody there to stop her.

[Martin]

Thanks for that Martin, perhaps 'Adam' might like to explain?

John Lamberton sometimes quotes Ian Stephens in that way, but he may not be the only one.

[maggie]

So true,Maggie. What were we like ? I probably didn't even know the proper meaning of hate neither.

Heat of the moment really lookout. Don't believe I have ever really hated anyone. 

[lookout]

Heat of the moment really lookout. Don't believe I have ever really hated anyone. 

Nor me,Maggie. It's so negative,and I'm not a negative person at all deep down.

[Neil]

If you think that it would be a good idea to try to forcibly disarm a person with a loaded weapon experiencing a psychotic episode then you are not thinking straight.

If my children were in the same house as an armed psychopath, I would not take my eyes off them for a moment

[Caroline R]

If my children were in the same house as an armed psychopath, I would not take my eyes off them for a moment

Oh, the power of hindsight! We all act differently for different reasons - as you weren't there and didn't see what happened - you can't say what you would do. You can only say what you 'think' you would do in a scenario influenced by what you think was happening.

[nugnug]

If my children were in the same house as an armed psychopath, I would not take my eyes off them for a moment

id like to think i would but to but in all honesty you dont no what you do if you have never been in such a situation.

[Jane]

If my children were in the same house as an armed psychopath, I would not take my eyes off them for a moment

So you may think now but circumstances change things.

[Neil]

Oh, the power of hindsight! We all act differently for different reasons - as you weren't there and didn't see what happened - you can't say what you would do. You can only say what you 'think' you would do in a scenario influenced by what you think was happening.

And that is exactly what I did.  I can't very well do anything else, can I?

Nobody knows conclusively what happened that night, therefor it is all about opinions. I am not offering up facts, merely expressing my opinion on the probability that certain things did or didn't happen. 

[Caroline R]

And that is exactly what I did.  I can't very well do anything else, can I?

Nobody knows conclusively what happened that night, therefor it is all about opinions. I am not offering up facts, merely expressing my opinion on the probability that certain things did or didn't happen.

With all respect, I haven't seen you offer up your own version of events, you've just criticised everyone else's.

[Neil]

With all respect, I haven't seen you offer up your own version of events, you've just criticised everyone else's.

I don't have any idea what happened.

I enjoy reading other posters theories and then questioning the validity of them. I am very open minded when it comes to this case.

Some people seem to take things too personally.

[Caroline R]

I don't have any idea what happened.

I enjoy reading other posters theories and then questioning the validity of them. I am very open minded when it comes to this case.

Some people seem to take things too personally.

People's ideas are personal!

[Neil]

People's ideas are personal!

If you don't like your ideas to be challenged, then I will not comment on them.

[Caroline R]

If you don't like your ideas to be challenged, then I will not comment on them.

I don't mind my ideas being challenged, neither (I assume) does Martin, as long as there is something constructive to debate with. Comments like "That sounds even more implausible" and "
The sequence of events, as suggested by Martin is quite simply, unbelievable" leaves no where to go as far as debate goes.