Book Reviews - Murders/Suicide at WHF

[Adam]

Actually Adam lookout is a free agent she can post anyway she likes..... thought you were moving on from all this, Lookout isn't on the forum to defend herself so can you stop discussing her and get back to the subject please.

My apologies.

It's just that other people were continuing to discuss it.

[susan]

She hasn't got links for what she says. Which is why she says 'find it yourself'.

She asked me for the evidence of why Sheila didn't commit the massacre. I posted 15 points.

She then asked the same question to you a few days later. 

Forgetfulness ?

Scipio says she ignores the evidence. Why ?

Adam

lookout does not ignore evidence she is so adamant Jeremy is innocent she just cannot see past it.  When I joined the forum at first I thought every word written on the Official Site must be true I did not question it at all and I think lookout is just the same.  I notice you believe what you read without a concrete sauce i.e. stuff out of books really is just how the Author sees it no evidence to confirm it.  One of my main problems with who committed the murders is just how clean Sheila was and her body appeared staged but this is how I see it lookout could see it differently that does not make her right and me wrong.  This case is so complex people are always going to perceive things and I doubt very much if we will ever know the whole truth just snippets and then the stuff we add.

[Adam]

Adam

lookout does not ignore evidence she is so adamant Jeremy is innocent she just cannot see past it.  When I joined the forum at first I thought every word written on the Official Site must be true I did not question it at all and I think lookout is just the same.  I notice you believe what you read without a concrete sauce i.e. stuff out of books really is just how the Author sees it no evidence to confirm it.  One of my main problems with who committed the murders is just how clean Sheila was and her body appeared staged but this is how I see it lookout could see it differently that does not make her right and me wrong.  This case is so complex people are always going to perceive things and I doubt very much if we will ever know the whole truth just snippets and then the stuff we add.

No I quote from Witness statements, internet articles, Youtube videos, books, police interviews, diaries, links other people post.

You know this as you said the information I gave you changed you're mind.

[Caroline]

Adam

lookout does not ignore evidence she is so adamant Jeremy is innocent she just cannot see past it.  When I joined the forum at first I thought every word written on the Official Site must be true I did not question it at all and I think lookout is just the same.  I notice you believe what you read without a concrete sauce i.e. stuff out of books really is just how the Author sees it no evidence to confirm it.  One of my main problems with who committed the murders is just how clean Sheila was and her body appeared staged but this is how I see it lookout could see it differently that does not make her right and me wrong.  This case is so complex people are always going to perceive things and I doubt very much if we will ever know the whole truth just snippets and then the stuff we add.

I think we have made it complicated by seeing a conspiracy where there isn't one. People have added things or taken them out of context to a point where many of the myths have been taken as fact. If you strip everything back and ignore what is said on the OS - the picture is much clearer.

[susan]

I think we have made it complicated by seeing a conspiracy where there isn't one. People have added things or taken them out of context to a point where many of the myths have been taken as fact. If you strip everything back and ignore what is said on the OS - the picture is much clearer.

Caroline good point I believe nothing now I read on the OS at one time I thought every word was true.

[Adam]

Caroline good point I believe nothing now I read on the OS at one time I thought every word was true.

That is the wrong approach.

Most of what is posted as fact is true. Backed up by sources by posters.

Everything on my 'new video' thread created yesterday is true. It discusses what is said in the video. People are allowed to say what was said on the video is wrong. Although most of it is 'primary' sources.

People's opinions are never wrong.

[Caroline]

That is the wrong approach.

Most of what is posted as fact is true. Backed up by sources by posters.

Everything on my 'new video' thread created yesterday is true. It discusses what is said in the video. People are allowed to say what was said on the video is wrong. Although most of it is 'primary' sources.

People's opinions are never wrong.

Eh? 

[susan]

Eh? 

Caroline

Eh? 

 

[susan]

No I quote from Witness statements, internet articles, Youtube videos, books, police interviews, diaries, links other people post.

You know this as you said the information I gave you changed you're mind.

Adam you are so right you had a big influence on me changing my stance. Thank you for that.

[Jan]

That is the wrong approach.

People's opinions are never wrong.

Well my opinion is that Jeremy is innocent and Julie did not tell the whole truth in court.

There that was simple wasn't it ?

[susan]

Well my opinion is that Jeremy is innocent and Julie did not tell the whole truth in court.

There that was simple wasn't it ?

Hahaha Jan I thought Adam was leaving himself wide open on this one unless it is a trick question

[Adam]

Well my opinion is that Jeremy is innocent and Julie did not tell the whole truth in court.

There that was simple wasn't it ?

Jan you must PM me if you are worried about changing stance.

I know you and Alias want to post, but know Scipio is about. But you can still post after changing stance,  just as others have done.

[Caroline]

Jan you must PM me if you are worried about changing stance.

I know you and Alias want to post, but know Scipio is about. But you can still post after changing stance,  just as others have done.

You should start holding your breath now!

[Adam]

You should start holding your breath now!

I should have given you the opportunity to PM me. My apologies.

The only other poster who I gave the opportunity to PM me was Lookout. But she errr believes Jeremy is innocent.

[Jan]

Jan you must PM me if you are worried about changing stance.

I know you and Alias want to post, but know Scipio is about. But you can still post after changing stance,  just as others have done.

You must watch that goading Adam - you have been warned. Several times .