Book Reviews - Murders/Suicide at WHF

[Caroline]

That's certain, is it?

She couldn't tell the truth if she wasn't told the truth!! 

[Jan]

She couldn't tell the truth if she wasn't told the truth!! 

or as Adam himself said - it just had a ring of truth.

[Jane]

or as Adam himself said - it just had a ring of truth.

Hmm. More like ONLY just

[Caroline]

Jeremy didn't tell Julie the truth - not the whole story, so she could only tell what she knew, if that wasn't the truth, then that's down to Jeremy.

[guest154]

Jeremy didn't tell Julie the truth - not the whole story, so she could only tell what she knew, if that wasn't the truth, then that's down to Jeremy.

Exactly. Her story wasn't what happened at WHF. It was was JEREMY told her happened.

[Jan]

Or - what the police wanted her to say and fed to her  in the "noble cause"


Thats my opinion and I am sticking to it.

[Caroline]

Or - what the police wanted her to say and fed to her  in the "noble cause"


Thats my opinion and I am sticking to it.

Why would they bother to invent a hit man? Why wouldn't they just get her to say that Jeremy told her he killed them?

[Adam]

Or - what the police wanted her to say and fed to her  in the "noble cause"


Thats my opinion and I am sticking to it.

That's it, the police told Julie what to say.

This was around the same time they told the lab technicians to contaminate the silencer and get the experts to give false evidence on Sheila's condition.

Poor Jeremy didn't know what had hit him after returning from St Tropez.

[Jan]

That's it, the police told Julie what to say.

This was around the same time they told the lab technicians to contaminate the silencer and get the experts to give false evidence on Sheila's condition.

Poor Jeremy didn't know what had hit him after returning from St Tropez.

the second part is your words not mine.

[Jan]

Why would they bother to invent a hit man? Why wouldn't they just get her to say that Jeremy told her he killed them?

because I think at one stage they thought he had an accomplice who had made the call from the house. I am not sure why . But I think they were under pressure for answers and at that point they had little evidence . 

[scipio_usmc]

because I think at one stage they thought he had an accomplice who had made the call from the house. I am not sure why . But I think they were under pressure for answers and at that point they had little evidence .

Making up a hitman is absurd. Fingering someone as that made up hitman is even more absurd. If you are going to make one up you say Jeremy never revealed the name.  You don't ID someone so that such person can provide an alibi and demolish the entire lie in short order.

[Adam]

Making up a hitman is absurd. Fingering someone as that made up hitman is even more absurd. If you are going to make one up you say Jeremy never revealed the name.  You don't ID someone so that such person can provide an alibi and demolish the entire lie in short order.

That's a good point.

If the police told Julie what to say, why would they tell her to mention MM ?

[Caroline]

because I think at one stage they thought he had an accomplice who had made the call from the house. I am not sure why . But I think they were under pressure for answers and at that point they had little evidence .

So they dragged MM out of nowhere?

[nugnug]

is pauls book out yet.

[lookout]

I don't think so nugs.