Why Jeremy Took Nevill's call so SERIOUSLY??

[Caroline]

those times do not match up at all with julies original statement . So to pick and chose times to suit a scenario is pretty pointless .

Well, that's what Jeremy is doing to fit in a call from Nevill!

[scipio_usmc]

those times do not match up at all with julies original statement . So to pick and chose times to suit a scenario is pretty pointless .

You mean the statement she gave to help Jeremy that she gave before she spoke to her roommates to ask them what time he called since she didn't look at the clock herself?

[notsure]

What im uncomfortable with is where it says ' got hold of one of my guns'

I realised you dan argue that point away but it doesnt feel right to me

[Caroline]

What im uncomfortable with is where it says ' got hold of one of my guns'

I realised you dan argue that point away but it doesnt feel right to me

West simply paraphrased what Jeremy told him - the evidence for this is the word 'Berserk'. West used the word to Bonnet instead of 'crazy' - how do we know that? because West used the word in his rolling log of events as they unfolded.

[lookout]

What im uncomfortable with is where it says ' got hold of one of my guns'

I realised you dan argue that point away but it doesnt feel right to me

" One of my guns " and not my rifle ?

[Caroline]

" One of my guns " and not my rifle ?

How is that relevant Lookout? The rifle was used to kill everyone! 

[Stephanie]

There are eyes everywhere and walls have ears! 

Totally! 

[lookout]

How is that relevant Lookout? The rifle was used to kill everyone! 

If he'd said rifle he'd have meant the rifle. Because he only stipulated " gun " it could have been any one of them that Sheila was waving/threatening but not necessarily using,which we now know.

[Jane]

" One of my guns " and not my rifle ?

Guns being a generic?

[lookout]

Guns being a generic?

But I feel pretty sure that Neville would have been precise.

[Jane]

But I feel pretty sure that Neville would have been precise.

Yes, I'm quite certain that in a moment of panic he'd have been precise.

[Caroline]

If he'd said rifle he'd have meant the rifle. Because he only stipulated " gun " it could have been any one of them that Sheila was waving/threatening but not necessarily using,which we now know.

And - not sure what your point is Lookout? West was paraphrasing but Jeremy also said gun - so?

[lookout]

And - not sure what your point is Lookout? West was paraphrasing but Jeremy also said gun - so?

It's as easy to say rifle as it is gun. It wouldn't have taken any more time.

[Caroline]

It's as easy to say rifle as it is gun. It wouldn't have taken any more time.

OK, Jeremy said Nevill said 'gun', Jeremy repeated 'gun' to West, West said 'gun'.  Are you saying that Nevill should have said 'rifle'? If so I don't understand your point - basically you're arguing against Jeremy! 

[David1819]

West simply paraphrased what Jeremy told him - the evidence for this is the word 'Berserk'. West used the word to Bonnet instead of 'crazy' - how do we know that? because West used the word in his rolling log of events as they unfolded.

He is saying the two dogs are going bezerk