New radio interviews

[scipio_usmc]

Yes however if you accept that they were possibly both seriously damaged people because of their adoption and possibly later trauma from further abandonment such as being sent to boarding school etc. it doesn't seem any more improbable than Jeremy Bamber dashing across ploughed fields in the pitch black, climbing through windows etc. imo.  Actually, I found the letter quite plausible and I don't know why because in theory it is crazy.

I find it quite plausible that Jeremy told such to another prisoner. I don't find the story in the letter plausible though- the part about him taking away Sheila's evidence stained clothing in particular is not in the least bit credible. 

[guest154]

If this is true about the Jack The Ripper book.... It's embaressing for PH...

"Yes, but Harrison researched the wrong Barnett. The book is largely ignored now."

I find it quite plausible that Jeremy told such to another prisoner. I don't find the story in the letter plausible though- the part about him taking away Sheila's evidence stained clothing in particular is not in the least bit credible. 

Agreed. I don't believe what Jeremy said will be true, but I do believe he may have said it.

[maggie]

I find it quite plausible that Jeremy told such to another prisoner. I don't find the story in the letter plausible though- the part about him taking away Sheila's evidence stained clothing in particular is not in the least bit credible.

I agree with that but the letter writer may have mixed that part up, I do agree and noticed that myself when I first read it that it makes no sense to remove the clothes when leaving them there would have completely got him off the hook.  I don't believe it's the whole truth but there may be something in it but chances are there isn't.  Keeping an open mind 

[nugnug]

cell mate confessions are dubious at the best of times anomalous one are beyond even that,

[Jane]

I think there are several issues here.

A. Do we believe a letter was sent

B. Do we believe it's contents

C. Do we believe Jeremy made the confession

D Do we believe the author of the letter made up Jeremy's confession

E Do we think the whole thing is a publicity stunt

Apologies if this sounds like one of Adam's polls.

[Caroline]

well the idea jeremy and sheila did it together as this seems to imply sounds ridiculous to me.

even more ridiculous is the idea that after lying to everybody for years he would suddenly disclose this to another prisoner.

But the idea that Jeremy is innocent and he was framed by EP, the relatives, Julie Mugford, the Sun Newspaper, the lab, the prosecution team, Julie's friends, his friends, the establishment, Babs Wilson ..... (please feel free to add to the list) makes perfect sense 

[nugnug]

But the idea that Jeremy is innocent and he was framed by EP, the relatives, Julie Mugford, the Sun Newspaper, the lab, the prosecution team, Julie's friends, his friends, the establishment, Babs Wilson ..... (please feel free to add to the list) makes perfect sense 

well its one thats suported by a lot of experts in there field were as the other one is the teory of one auther allefedly backed an anoumous letter/

[guest154]

well its one thats suported by a lot of experts in there field were as the other one is the teory of one auther allefedly backed an anoumous letter/

Paid 'experts' can say anything they like though, the COA and the CCRC cut through their gaffs.

[nugnug]

they got no reason to lie its not like there short of work.

[susan]

Yes however if you accept that they were possibly both seriously damaged people because of their adoption and possibly later trauma from further abandonment such as being sent to boarding school etc. it doesn't seem any more improbable than Jeremy Bamber dashing across ploughed fields in the pitch black, climbing through windows etc. imo.  Actually, I found the letter quite plausible and I don't know why because in theory it is crazy and doesn't even make sense.

Maggie what parts of the letter did you find plausible.? 

[nugnug]

doesnt anyone think its a bit funny that none of the other ever recive anomous letters.

[guest154]

they got no reason to lie its not like there short of work.

Didn't say they lie, but they are only giving their opinions. No guarantee that they are correct. They often have to rely on photographs because they were not there at the time.

doesnt anyone think its a bit funny that none of the other ever recive anomous letters.

With some of the people I've met just through this forum and the red forum when it comes to the Bamber case, I would not be shocked if PH recieved 1, 2 or 10 anonymous letters. 

[Caroline]

well its one thats suported by a lot of experts in there field were as the other one is the teory of one auther allefedly backed an anoumous letter/

What experts?

[Caroline]

doesnt anyone think its a bit funny that none of the other ever recive anomous letters.

How do you know they didn't?

[nugnug]

well i think if they had recived such anoumous letter they might of mentioned it but appwerantly who ever gets sent these letters.