The Myths of Circumstantial Evidence

[lookout]

No you do it.

I suggest you start reading. There is a lot.

I asked YOU.    I CAN'T do it because there ISN'T any. Maybe you're more observant.

[Adam]

You have asked me several times and I always answer. Perhaps you forget. Or don't want to take it in.

Anyway my thread 'Was there really no forensic evidence' has been up for months.

There is also the evidence that Sheila did not do anything. But as Jan said. The police may have cleaned her up before the pathologist and crime scene investigators arrived.

[scipio_usmc]

In his statement in Sept he denied he used the phrases the police were accusing him of. So his word against thier. I was just suggesting they could have embellished what he said to cover up why they did not go in straight away. Or as you said they may have forgotten as it was a month later. But it does mean if that was true he did not set the situation to stop them going in . In fact he begged them to go in and never indicated that any shots had been fired and perhaps did not say she had fired every weapon in the house - which is what I was getting at.

Too many police said it, even Mercer the dog handler.  It is hard to believe all the cops got together to lie.

[Caroline]

In his statement in Sept he denied he used the phrases the police were accusing him of. So his word against thier. I was just suggesting they could have embellished what he said to cover up why they did not go in straight away. Or as you said they may have forgotten as it was a month later. But it does mean if that was true he did not set the situation to stop them going in . In fact he begged them to go in and never indicated that any shots had been fired and perhaps did not say she had fired every weapon in the house - which is what I was getting at.

Well, he would. The police wouldn't have gone in their straight away anyway, not when there was the potential of meeting an armed suspect. Who said he begged them to go in? Was that Bews? I thought people didn't believe a word he said?

[Jan]

You have asked me several times and I always answer. Perhaps you forget. Or don't want to take it in.

Anyway my thread 'Was there really no forensic evidence' has been up for months.

There is also the evidence that Sheila did not do anything. But as Jan said. The police may have cleaned her up before the pathologist and crime scene investigators arrived.

EXCUSE ME -    show me where I said the police may have cleaned her up - or you are a liar

[Jan]

Too many police said it, even Mercer the dog handler.  It is hard to believe all the cops got together to lie.

 

It has been known

[Jan]

EXCUSE ME -     show me where I said the police may have cleaned her up - or you are a liar

STILL WAITING 

[Caroline]

It has been known

For something big, not a domestic murder/suicide 

[Jan]

For something big, not a domestic murder/suicide 

well as I don't know the details of every single MOJ in the country I cant comment.

perhaps this is the first

[Caroline]

well as I don't know the details of every single MOJ in the country I cant comment.

perhaps this is the first

Sorry I got distracted - could have sworn I saw a flying pig 

[Jan]

Sorry I got distracted - could have sworn I saw a flying pig 

No that was the last word flying past . The one you always have to have 

[Jan]

EXCUSE ME -    show me where I said the police may have cleaned her up - or you are a liar

Still waiting Adam

[Caroline]

No that was the last word flying past . The one you always have to have 

Not that anyone could accuse you of that - right? 

[Jan]

I would answer - but that might be the last word - so I wont 

[Caroline]

I would answer - but that might be the last word - so I wont 

Me either