Ann Eaton´s Notes.

[Jane]

That's where you're mistaken because AE found a fingernail,either false or real and I would like to know where she found it.
I don't dream !!

Could it have fallen from a make-up bag?

[lookout]

Ann wrote her notes when she said she wrote them, unless there is proof/evidence existing that shows otherwise - anything else is just speculation.

Are you talking a different case again??   

You can't help it,can you ? 
 If you read it properly,instead of seeing what YOU want to see,it's about Ann Eaton--------------and yes,she found a fingernail belonging to Sheila,who else,Neville ??

[lookout]

Could it have fallen from a make-up bag?

Nope--------------AE PUT it in the make-up bag after she'd found it.

[susan]

Hello lookout

I read on this forum about this nail I seem to think it was a small bit that had broken off a toe nail and was found near the aga I have not imagined it (Mat) but cannot say if this was fact or another myth.

[guest154]

I wonder where she found the fingernail ? The one which broke off when Sheila gouged into the flesh of her parents. ?

So finding a nail turns into this? It's you that can't help yourself - make it up as you go.

Could it have fallen from a make-up bag?

I'm not convinced that one was found and if one was, it wasn't missing from Sheila - not that I've read. Consider the source.

Hello lookout

I read on this forum about this nail I seem to think it was a small bit that had broken off a toe nail and was found near the aga I have not imagined it (Mat) but cannot say if this was fact or another myth.

That's not what's being claimed though, a toe nail. Lookout is claiming the nail came off when gouges were made on her parents - surely not with her toe?

[lookout]

Hello lookout

I read on this forum about this nail I seem to think it was a small bit that had broken off a toe nail and was found near the aga I have not imagined it (Mat) but cannot say if this was fact or another myth.

Hi Susan,it sounded more like a false one that became detached ------------through force,as it would.

[lookout]

As well as a piece of toenail too. Rather in the wars,wasn't she ?

[guest154]

As well as a piece of toenail too. Rather in the wars,wasn't she ?

In your mind, yes. But in reality no - I am sure Scip will correct you again on the nails...and what marks where and weren't on her parents. Because clearly you're talking a different case again. 

[scipio_usmc]

That's where you're mistaken because AE found a fingernail,either false or real and I would like to know where she found it.
I don't dream !!

I never saw any reference to a fingernail being found.  In ANY event, if one was found it wasn't SHeila's because hers were fully intact.  It would rather be like alleging I bit someone and left my tooth behind when I have all my teeth. 

I already posted the autopsy section related to June's arms to show you that you were wrong about her having a nail mark.  I don't understand why you don't absorb the information presented to you and to use it going forward instead of making disproved claims again.  You are tilting at windmills.  This is the section on injuries other than the bullet wounds and her arms are not mentioned at all:

[guest154]

I never saw any reference to a fingernail being found.  In ANY event, if one was found it wasn't SHeila's because hers were fulling intact.  It would rather be like alleging I bit someone and left my tooth behind when I have all my teeth. 

I already posted the autopsy section related to June's arms to show you that you were wrong about her having a nail mark.  I don't understand why you don't absorb the information presented to you and to use it going forward instead of making disproved claims again.  You are tilting at windmills.  This is the section on injuries other than the bullet wounds and her arms are not mentioned at all:

Lookout clearly doesn't know what she is talking about - she has posted these wild claims about marks on June before and has been provided with the autopsy report to prove her wrong - but here we go again.

Ah, you beat me to posting the page.

[Jane]

Nope--------------AE PUT it in the make-up bag after she'd found it.

It doesn't mean it can't have fallen out. It's been suggested that plods or dogs could transfer shell cases from room to room, so I'm perfectly certain that a false nail could have transferred itself via a sock or slipper. More, unless Sheila was found to have had a full set -minus one- of false nails OR a natural nail was found to have been ripped out of the nail bed, we must assume that a false nail hadn't been attached to Sheila that night.

[susan]

Hi Susan,it sounded more like a false one that became detached ------------through force,as it would.

lookout I just remember toenail, and something about a false nail or something found in a make up bag  but I will be honest and say I cannot remember a whole nail being found but none of it is very clear in my mind

[scipio_usmc]

As well as a piece of toenail too. Rather in the wars,wasn't she ?

She was not missing any of her toenails either, how many times do we have to go over this? Her toenails had some of the varnish wearing off her nails. Sutherst made the absurd claim he matched the shape of a tiny red speck in a kitchen photo to the exact shape of her varnish missing from one of her toes.   You took his varnish claim and misconstrued it as a piece of her nail.

I am not trying to be mean I am trying to help you so that you don't look silly by continuously making this claim.

[susan]

She was not missing any of her toenails either, how many times do we have to go over this? Her toenails had some of the varnish wearing off her nails. Sutherst made the absurd claim he matched the shape of a tiny red speck in a kitchen photo to the exact shape of her varnish missing from one of her toes.   You took his varnish claim and misconstrued it as a piece of her nail.

I am not trying to be mean I am trying to help you so that you don't look silly by continuously making this claim.

Scipio  you have brought it all back to me now it was a chip off the nail varnish on Sheila's toes that was found on the floor.  Thanks for clarifying that.   

[Jane]

Hello lookout

I read on this forum about this nail I seem to think it was a small bit that had broken off a toe nail and was found near the aga I have not imagined it (Mat) but cannot say if this was fact or another myth.

Although I have no previous knowledge of June having been gouged -any more than I recall Sheila being minus a nail- I'm fairly confident that HAD she been, it would NOT have been with a fragment of broken toenail.