FACT she could have been telling lies in the second statement in order to help the police with their noble cause. she is the only one who knows the truth
This is a perfect example of how you ignore reality constantly.
Her first stoy of why he phoned made no sense. The acocutn where she came clean placed the call in persepctive and makes sense. Moreover, the claims are corroborated by the evidence which proves Sheila didn't kill her self or anyone else.
The first account is the one that has no credence. Receiving a call from his father saying his sister was in a crazy rage with a gun come quick to help imports an emergency. Someone receiving that call would either rush over or phone police. They would not call their girlfriend to ask for advice of what to do or for consolation as opposed to trying to do something to help.
Of course there is considerable evidence the clal from nevill couldn't have happened, his supposed reaciton not comporting with how someone receiving suhc a call would act just adds more evidence to the pile.
So ? she had plenty of time to collude with them by September?Anyway they all said different times - so no help there.
Why would the roomates have a reason to collude against Jeremy? If they colluded they would all say the same thing moreover. The times they gave ruled out the chance of the call being after Jeremy had phoned police. That is extremely helpful in proving he called her before police.
He did not consider it an emergency - he had no idea what was about to happen personally I think he may have phoned Julie inbetween calls and then thought it made him look bad - if he was going to set up the proper Siege situation to stop the police going in he could have said she had fired a shot - but as he had not they culd have just gone over seen it was all quiet and knocked on the door
If shots had already been fired that would suggest they were already killed and there would be less of a neeed to wait to try to save the hostages.
In the meantime there is no question he called Julie before police. Your admission he didn't consider it an emeregency is fatal because it proves he didn't receive the call he claimed. No rational person woudl consider it not an emergency if their father claims a crazy person had a gun and that they needed you to come help disarm such person. It makes no sense at all.
Since Sheila can't have killed herself or anyone else that means there is no reason Nevill would make such a call. Nor would he have had the opportunity to make such a call because the shooting started in a room where there was no phone. It is alreayd quite clear no such phone call ever came from Nevill Jeremy's alleged reaction just shows even more it never happened and that he made it up.
