JB petition now has almost ten thousand signatures.

[lookout]

It was a good question which was posed by Reader which would have required an equally good answer but sadly didn't come forthwith. Instead it was the usual frosty reply when you find yourself browbeaten.

[Caroline]

It was a good question which was posed by Reader which would have required an equally good answer but sadly didn't come forthwith. Instead it was the usual frosty reply when you find yourself browbeaten.

Reader didn't ask a question, he/she did the usual arse about face critique, made wrong assumptions and certainly would never have the good grace to make an apology. So yes, frosty is as frosty does. My past experiences of this poster have allowed me to form certain opinions.

By the way, they had a go at you also! 

[Caroline]

It was a good question which was posed by Reader which would have required an equally good answer but sadly didn't come forthwith. Instead it was the usual frosty reply when you find yourself browbeaten.

Oh you mean this little gem?

Aren't you making an assumption as to when he got dressed? I don't recall that Jeremy ever gave details about that.

It is possible to make certain assumptions - if you believe Jeremy is innocent then he had to get dressed after the supposed call from his father and before leaving the house (common sense). Personally, I don't think he did get dressed but as Reader does, when does he/she think it happened? Not that it makes any difference but Reader is making a meal of it so lets have their opinion! Or is no one allowed an 'opinion'? If that is the case no one should be posting.

[lookout]

Let's face it, in your books no-one IS allowed an opinion if it differs from yours !

[Caroline]

Let's face it, in your books no-one IS allowed an opinion if it differs from yours !

Lets face it, you never stop giving yours so that makes that comments obsolete!

[lookout]

Lets face it, you never stop giving yours so that makes that comments obsolete!

Blimey, you can talk. You don't even give people a chance to voice their opinion.   

[Caroline]

Blimey, you can talk. You don't even give people a chance to voice their opinion.

When have you ever been stopped from voicing yours?

[lookout]

When have you ever been stopped from voicing yours?

I'm not talking about me I'm talking about those who've disappeared off the scene. I'd like to meet the person who stops me from having my say.
There was no need whatsoever to have spoken to Reader as you did was there ?

[Caroline]

I'm not talking about me I'm talking about those who've disappeared off the scene. I'd like to meet the person who stops me from having my say.
There was no need whatsoever to have spoken to Reader as you did was there ?

People leaving the forum is NOTHING to do with me - and if Reader wasn't so RUDE she/he might receive a better response. These are adults Lookout and I am not here to pacify ANYONE!

[Jane]

Aren't you making an assumption as to when he got dressed? I don't recall that Jeremy ever gave details about that.

Can you give me one good reason why I should not have? We have been led to believe that Jeremy was in bed when he allegedly received a call from his father at silly o'clock. Now I have no idea whether he slept in pj's, underpants, nightshirt, or nude, but it's reasonable to ASSUME it may have been one of those. It also seems reasonable to ASSUME that as he arrived at the murder scene dressed in day clothes, he had, at some point, dressed, however, I can't tell you the exact moment he did that. I can only ASSUME it was at some point between being woken from sleep -if that's what you care to believe happened- and leaving the house.

The call -the time of which I wrongly gave as being 11 minutes (although as I wasn't certain I seem to think I added a question mark?)- that I experienced you as being hell bent on putting me in the wrong over, was the earlier one.

Perhaps next time you could drop the hostile bull in a china shop attitude.

[lookout]

Reader isn't a rude person. None of her posts have ever upset anyone.

[nugnug]

well how would it have taken him to dtrss not long.

[lookout]

I suppose this particular argument lets JB off the hook that he was at his own home getting dressed instead of allegedly in hiding at WHF before the murders, suggesting that he didn't go home at all.

[Jane]

Reader isn't a rude person. None of her posts have ever upset anyone.

Perhaps you should try asking "anyone" instead of "knowing" what is their experience of Reader.

[Jane]

well how would it have taken him to dtrss not long.

I don't know, nugs. I wasn't there, but the length of time it would have taken him to dress isn't what's being discussed here. It appears to be about what right did I have to assume he dressed. Actually, I never believed he UNdressed.