This has probably been discussed many times before but I think its worth a refresh.
I find it shocking that the Judge said it could 'only have been JEREMY or SHEILA'.
Theory:
SHEILA was desperately ill and wanted to kill her family, but couldn't do it herself.
She confided in a 'friend' 'X' who was a sicko and 'he' said "I'll do it", "but you will have to take your own life, I cant kill a 'friend'"
SHEILA "Okay but I want JEREMY rid of Evil as well, and it must be after dark"
X "okay but how do I access and exit the house"
SHEILA "I will allow you in, and allow you out"
X "okay, but what about JEREMY"
SHEILA "you will have to point a rifle at my dads head and say, "phone your son and say 'your sister has the gun and gone berserk'
when he (JEREMY) comes to the house kill the evil devil as well.
X "yes, but what about you, and again access, exit?
SHEILA "I will let you in and out, and then wash myself and prepare for my final journey"
X "okay"
JEREMY should have died at the hands of the 'X' that fateful night, but 'by luck' he didn't
Phone call by NEVILLE to police, not sure how that happened, but stranger things have occured. and I need more time to think about this important point.
I guess 'quilters' will say 'above could have been JEREMY', well I don't believe that but again JUDGE misguided jury.