mugford rwb and the order of death.

[Kaldin]

These are your projections Kaldin

Own them instead on attempting to dump them on to others

Says the person who made a snidy comment about me. That's your MO though isn't it? You make a snidy comment and then you don't like it when the person replies to you.

[lookout]

It's like this claim that the "guilters" make that Nevill wouldn't have left guns lying around the house, but didn't Ann Eaton said there were guns lying around the house when she went there?

Yes,the shotgun was upstairs,found by AE. I think it was in the upstairs office.

[Jane]

Sheila went on shoots. I'm sure she didn't just stand looking into space,she'd have been watching each and every member loading up ready to shoot their target. When someone sees how it's done on many occasions,the farm too,they DO grasp how it's done. Her father may have shown her,who knows ? Sheila had been brought up on a farm so she WOULD have known how to load a rifle,even if it had been one at a time.

That's a VERY sweeping statement. It's simply NOT a given that all those bought up on farms know how to load guns or shoot.

[Jane]

It's like this claim that the "guilters" make that Nevill wouldn't have left guns lying around the house, but didn't Ann Eaton said there were guns lying around the house when she went there?

Sweeping statements are no more universally true from "guilters" than they are from supporters.

[guest154]

It's like this claim that the "guilters" make that Nevill wouldn't have left guns lying around the house, but didn't Ann Eaton said there were guns lying around the house when she went there?

AE saw a loaded weapon left on the kitchen table whilst the twins were over? If not, you're comparing apples and oranges.  Because it is the fact that the weapon was left loaded on the kitchen table that "guilters" sturggle to believe.

[lookout]

That's a VERY sweeping statement. It's simply NOT a given that all those bought up on farms know how to load guns or shoot.

Sweeping statement nothing.A child of three who's brought up on a farm knows how to use guns.Get real !

[Jane]

Of course he could.

I imagine one of his attractions for Sheila might have been that he couldn't have been further away from the farming society that a quirk of fate had assigned her to.

[maggie]

AE saw a loaded weapon left on the kitchen table whilst the twins were over? If not, you're comparing apples and oranges.  Because it is the fact that the weapon was left loaded on the kitchen table that "guilters" sturggle to believe.

I thought the rifle was left by the settle not on the kitchen table.

[Kaldin]

Yes,the shotgun was upstairs,found by AE. I think it was in the upstairs office.

Ann said it one statement that David collected all the guns from around the house. Does that not suggest that the guns were not in one place?

[Kaldin]

AE saw a loaded weapon left on the kitchen table whilst the twins were over? If not, you're comparing apples and oranges.  Because it is the fact that the weapon was left loaded on the kitchen table that "guilters" sturggle to believe.

That's not what I said. See my previous post.

The gun was not left on the kitchen table anyway. It can't have been - there were bowls left on the table. The gun was left on or near to the settle in the adjacent room.

[maggie]

That's not what I said. See my previous post.

The gun was not left on the kitchen table anyway. It can't have been - there were bowls left on the table. The gun was left on or near to the settle in the adjacent room.

Exactly kaldin

[Kaldin]

Exactly kaldin

I see you just said that yourself. 

[guest154]

I thought the rifle was left by the settle not on the kitchen table.

The case has been out of my mind for a year.  But the point remains the same. Loaded weapon left out.

DO you have an opinion on it? Or just posting to correct me? 

[Kaldin]

The case has been out of my mind for a year.  But the point remains the same. Loaded weapon left out.

DO you have an opinion on it? Or just posting to correct me? 

The question is - did Nevill really put all guns away at night or not?

[lookout]

Ann said it one statement that David collected all the guns from around the house. Does that not suggest that the guns were not in one place?

It does indeed.