What makes Bamber innocent?

[Adam]

It was mentioned in court at trial.  Rivlin briefly touched upon it in cross examination of one of the police officers.  Strangely in my view he sought to downplay it, supporting the assertion that it was a mere trick of the light and not seeking to explore any other possibility.  I have never understood the reason for that.  Even the possibility that someone might have been alive in the house at that time would have been enough to secure an acquittal.

Who made the first sighting of the 'trick of the light' ?

[mike tesko]

if pc myall saw someone leaving he would have chased him and apprehended him he knew back up was on its way

No, he wouldn't since by that stage Myall, Bews, and Saxby, didn't know that a shot had been fired by 'that' stage...

[mike tesko]

Let's look at the scenario. There's a siege situation in which an allegedly insane female is running around with a gun when all of a sudden an "uniden...............you know the rest" THEN is seen "leaving from ect..." and they let him walk past!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! J, M & J have you ever heard such RUBBISH??

Where has it be stated, that PC Myall let the 'unidentified' male, walk past? You should take time out to read, 'Kim Sengupta's news article. It reads, ' and who was the scruffy looking hunched man seen walking away from the scene about an hour after police first arrived at the farmhouse'...

This information was 'published' in a national tabloid - are you suggesting it was 'not true', and if so, where is your evidence for saying that?

[mike tesko]

thats the correct word for that theory jane laughable and childish could also be used

Refer to 'Kim Senguptas' article...

[Jane]

Where has it be stated, that PC Myall let the 'unidentified' male, walk past? You should take time out to read, 'Kim Sengupta's news article. It reads, ' and who was the scruffy looking hunched man seen walking away from the scene about an hour after police first arrived at the farmhouse'...

This information was 'published' in a national tabloid - are you suggesting it was 'not true', and if so, where is your evidence for saying that?

SWell, as KS wasn't at the SOC it can't be proved that it was true and as I'm not naming names, it stands to reason that if the SLHM was seen walking away -the emphasis being on SEEN- why didn't A police person stop them? However, when it comes to what newspapers report, are you honestly saying you believe every word they print is the truth?

[sami]

Refer to 'Kim Senguptas' article...

who is she mike

[lookout]

Refer to 'Kim Senguptas' article...

Kim's a brilliant crime reporter.

[JackiePreece]

Apart from what I have posted in response to the two earlier posts, it is something I discussed with Jeremy a while back.  He recalled Bews taking the sighting very seriously.  This again is a reason I am surprised at how the defence failed to use this to their advantage at trial.  Rivlin may have had good reasons for the course he took, but I have no idea what that reason might be.

Thank you NGB

xxx    One from me and one from each of my horses 

[sami]

No, he wouldn't since by that stage Myall, Bews, and Saxby, didn't know that a shot had been fired by 'that' stage...

the person was leaving a crime scene doesnt matter if no shots were heard the police would have challanged him

[mike tesko]

SWell, as KS wasn't at the SOC it can't be proved that it was true and as I'm not naming names, it stands to reason that if the SLHM was seen walking away -the emphasis being on SEEN- why didn't A police person stop them? However, when it comes to what newspapers report, are you honestly saying you believe every word they print is the truth?

No-one has come forward to say anything which discredits what Kim Sengupta wrote about, so why shouldn't it be true?

[sami]

Kim's a brilliant crime reporter.

would you say the same about crime reporters who say jb is guilty and a childkiller

[Caroline]

Thank you NGB

xxx    One from me and one from each of my horses 

(Hope NGB has a bucket handy!  )

[Caroline]

would you say the same about crime reporters who say jb is guilty and a childkiller

Of course not! 

[Jane]

(Hope NGB has a bucket handy!  )

To pick up her poo and put on his roses?

[mike tesko]

the person was leaving a crime scene doesnt matter if no shots were heard the police would have challanged him

If cops reported finding 'two bodies downstairs in the kitchen' from as long ago as 7.37am, and the other 'three bodies upstairs' by 8.10am, they wouldn't deliberately lie about it, unless 'cops did something they ought not to have done', with 'one of the two bodies downstairs' ending 'up dead upstairs', is a far more 'compelling' argument, than your suggestion that 'if' an 'unidentified' male had walked away from the scene that PC Myalls would have challenged him, or even arrested him..