The Murders at White House Farm - By Carol Ann Lee (A Taster!)

[Patti]

That wouldn't explain who shot Sheila. If that is the story of the book - I will throw it in the ocean!

The claim is that Jeremy told Sheila to cleanse herself then Jeremy shot Sheila.

I am only repeating hearsay, I have not read it yet. I don't think it will be a best seller Mat....I also hear he mentions the threats made to him.

[Jan]

And she beat up Neville - which would be against all arguments that she would not be capable of doing so.

Is it worth reading for any new information at all ?

[guest154]

The claim is that Jeremy told Sheila to cleanse herself then Jeremy shot Sheila.

I am only repeating hearsay, I have not read it yet. I don't think it will be a best seller Mat....I also hear he mentions the threats made to him.

Wait.

Are we talking CAL or PH? I thought we were talking about Carol Ann Lees book.

[Jan]

Wait.

Are we talking CAL or PH? I thought we were talking about Carol Ann Lees book.

no the bits above are from the book the deviant

[maggie]

And she beat up Neville - which would be against all arguments that she would not be capable of doing so.

Is it worth reading for any new information at all ?

Am reading interviews with the police involved, I find that interesting particularly about Taff Jones, have a way to go yet.
Read the last chapter first 

[Patti]

Wait.

Are we talking CAL or PH? I thought we were talking about Carol Ann Lees book.

Sorry my mistake I did not read the thread title. I'm talking about PH....but, I feel sure that no matter who it was that your sentiments are the same about throwing the book in the ocean.

[guest154]

no the bits above are from the book the deviant

Oh, I see. I thought we were still talking about CAL's book.  I will wait until I read PH's book for myself, because if it contains the sort of things that PH claimed it would then supporters will want to talk the book down before it is released.

Sorry my mistake I did not read the thread title. I'm talking about PH....but, I feel sure that no matter who it was that your sentiments are the same about throwing the book in the ocean.

Yup, I would!
I was just confused why you were calling CAL a HE 

[maggie]

Oh, I see. I will wait until I read PH's book for myself, because if it contains the sort of things that PH claimed it would then supporters will want to talk the book down before it is released.

Not necessarily, I believe most 'supporters' on this forum are just interested in the truth.

[guest154]

Not necessarily, I believe most 'supporters' on this forum are just interested in the truth.

I wasn't talking about on here, because I don't think anyone on here has read it.

But to be honest  you can see that some supporters here are already bashing the book BEFORE they have even read them, which is no surprise.

[maggie]

I wasn't talking about on here, because I don't think anyone on here has read it.

But to be honest  you can see that some supporters here are already bashing the book BEFORE they have even read them, which is no surprise.

I have the book and am reading it. It was delivered from Amazon yesterday.

[guest154]

I have the book and am reading it. It was delivered from Amazon yesterday.

Well still I would prefer to read it for myself!

SOME supporters are slating it before having read it. And that started months ago.

[maggie]

Well still I would prefer to read it for myself!

SOME supporters are slating it before having read it. And that started months ago.

Fair enough.

[scipio_usmc]

LOL

I have heard that the book is an embarrassing read and that the smoking gun is that Sheila did it and Jeremy encouraged it, witnessed it and told an inmate all about it.  The inmate sent a letter with this info on it....Honestly you could not make it up...

That is precisely the kind of story inmates make up to tell one another and even to try to use to escape liability by telling such to a court.  It is quite possible Jeremy did make up such and tell it to someone but believing it is another matter entirely.  If an author is actually claiming that it is true because Jeremy says so to a fellow inmate that is pretty funny.

 

 

[Adam]

The claim is that Jeremy told Sheila to cleanse herself then Jeremy shot Sheila.

I am only repeating hearsay, I have not read it yet. I don't think it will be a best seller Mat....I also hear he mentions the threats made to him.

What is the point in Bamber telling Sheila to cleanse herself ? She had just got out of bed so would have already been clean.

Bamber would have wanted everyone dead as quickly as possible with the minimum of fuss. 

[susan]

What is the point in Bamber telling Sheila to cleanse herself ? She had just got out of bed so would have already been clean.

Bamber would have wanted everyone dead as quickly as possible with the minimum of fuss.

Adam

I agree why would Jeremy tell Sheila to shower and change her clothes it would have been much more authentic that she was the killer had she had blood splatter on her and gun residue then he took her clothes away.  Not buying that at all.  Skipio explained all this in an earlier post to me.