The Murders at White House Farm - By Carol Ann Lee (A Taster!)

[susan]

Ok Mat - when you come back off holiday we will have a little book review thread.

But like I said only posters who can debate like adults allowed !

And  even posters who have made up their minds should try and discuss from both angles - its makes it more interesting I find.

Hahaha Jan by the time Mat gets back from holiday we will have all killed each other so he can debate with himself

[susan]

I look forward to reading the book, am hoping there will be some new info in it.

Hello Maggie

Caroline said we have new information ahead can't wait

[Jan]

Oh, there is 

Oh dear - you are doing the same as you accuse lookout of doing.

[Caroline]

Oh dear - you are doing the same as you accuse lookout of doing.

I know 

[maggie]

Hello Maggie

Caroline said we have new information ahead can't wait

I do hope so we need some new posters and new info to stimulate debate.
 also agree with Jan that we need proper reasoned debate from every angle rather than point scoring.

[Jan]

Hello Maggie

Caroline said we have new information ahead can't wait

Well If there is new information I trust it has been directed through the correct channels to stop any further appeals - because that would be the correct thing to do .

[Jan]

I do hope so we need some new posters and new info to stimulate debate.
 also agree with Jan that we need proper reasoned debate from every angle rather than point scoring.

we can all do it if we try , well most of us anyway.

[Jane]

Stranger things have happened. Though now it's beginning to sound like a mass vendetta even if he is presumed innocent,for it's the power of the public that'll keep him where he is and NOT so much the legal system. Let's face it,it only needs the usual war-cry from the relatives saying that " they all fear for their lives " and that'll be the end of any more thoughts of appealing, that would be my reason for his continued incarceration even if his innocence is proven.
Too many people have too much to lose otherwise !!   

Lookout, it has nothing to do with the public. If you read my quote from "The ESSEX Triangle" you can see the -ALLEGED- words said by the trial judge.

[susan]

I do hope so we need some new posters and new info to stimulate debate.
 also agree with Jan that we need proper reasoned debate from every angle rather than point scoring.

Maggie much better for us all to have a real good scrap

[Caroline]

Maggie much better for us all to have a real good scrap

That's the way it usually goes!

[Jane]

Stranger things have happened. Though now it's beginning to sound like a mass vendetta even if he is presumed innocent,for it's the power of the public that'll keep him where he is and NOT so much the legal system. Let's face it,it only needs the usual war-cry from the relatives saying that " they all fear for their lives " and that'll be the end of any more thoughts of appealing, that would be my reason for his continued incarceration even if his innocence is proven.
Too many people have too much to lose otherwise !!   

It sounds like you've already got an answer ready when the next submission fails, Lookout

[susan]

That's the way it usually goes!

Caroline we don't do gentle debate

[lookout]

Lookout, it has nothing to do with the public. If you read my quote from "The ESSEX Triangle" you can see the -ALLEGED- words said by the trial judge.

I don't need to read anything April,it's just the feeling I get. If the rellies can complain and bring about a  change in the category status,then anything is possible. 

[Jan]

Stranger things have happened. Though now it's beginning to sound like a mass vendetta even if he is presumed innocent,for it's the power of the public that'll keep him where he is and NOT so much the legal system. Let's face it,it only needs the usual war-cry from the relatives saying that " they all fear for their lives " and that'll be the end of any more thoughts of appealing, that would be my reason for his continued incarceration even if his innocence is proven.
Too many people have too much to lose otherwise !!   

I would guess that any author would hopefully spend a lot of time on research and should go in open minded and I think the timings are more to do with the 30 year anniversary than anything else .

If what has been inferred about the appeal is correct - then the book will be irrelevant. But if it contains new evidence that is valid then it should be used through the correct channels.

[maggie]

Maggie much better for us all to have a real good scrap

You're a hooligan Susie