Michael Fielder Proven liar

[lookout]

He didn't sound 'panicky' because he didn't call.

Well there are 6 logs to say that Neville did call,albeit copied/edited retaining the same mistakes that were originally made.

[Jane]

Not if it's all been heard before in similar circumstances------------of which we don't know of as yet.

There has been NOTHING to suggest it had, Lookout, not even from Jeremy who would SURELY have said if it had been a regular occurrence.  There have been no stories of Jeremy accompanying his father to London to calm Sheila down -a journey THEN of possibly 2 hours- and on no more than 2 occasions is it documented that Neville did. If we started releasing all of those who protest their innocence on the grounds that it MAY have been heard before in similar circumstances -IMO, another way of straw clutching- our prisons would very soon have fewer residents.

[lookout]

There has been NOTHING to suggest it had, Lookout, not even from Jeremy who would SURELY have said if it had been a regular occurrence.  There have been no stories of Jeremy accompanying his father to London to calm Sheila down -a journey THEN of possibly 2 hours- and on no more than 2 occasions is it documented that Neville did. If we started releasing all of those who protest their innocence on the grounds that it MAY have been heard before in similar circumstances -IMO, another way of straw clutching- our prisons would very soon have fewer residents.

I already knew that Neville hadn't travelled to London to calm Sheila down.He went next day as he'd said he would and not straight-away.( not that this is relevant,it isn't ? )
It's not ME who's clutching at straws. I couldn't give a monkeys.

[Caroline]

Well there are 6 logs to say that Neville did call,albeit copied/edited retaining the same mistakes that were originally made.

Yes, I have copies of these logs and they ALL contain the same information, except Tolleshunt is spelled incorrectly on one of them. None of these logs prove Nevill called because they are copies of West's log - from JEREMY'S call. Had they been the Bonnet log, it might have been more interesting!! 

[Jane]

Well there are 6 logs to say that Neville did call,albeit copied/edited retaining the same mistakes that were originally made.

I don't believe I've EVER seen a log stating that a call had been received from Mr Neville -OR, if you prefer, RALPH- Bamber to say that his daughter had gone mad and had got hold of a gun. The only one I've seen is the one which states that a call had been received from Mr JEREMY Bamber saying he'd received a call from his father..........................this call being passed from one operative to another.

[Caroline]

I don't believe I've EVER seen a log stating that a call had been received from Mr Neville -OR, if you prefer, RALPH- Bamber to say that his daughter had gone mad and had got hold of a gun. The only one I've seen is the one which states that a call had been received from Mr JEREMY Bamber saying he'd received a call from his father..........................this call being passed from one operative to another.

Because there isn't one 

[Jane]

I already knew that Neville hadn't travelled to London to calm Sheila down.He went next day as he'd said he would and not straight-away.( not that this is relevant,it isn't ? )
It's not ME who's clutching at straws. I couldn't give a monkeys.

But it IS you who is suggesting the possibility that it MAY "all have been heard before in similar circumstances" which doesn't sound like someone who doesn't give a monkey's.

[lookout]

Yes, I have copies of these logs and they ALL contain the same information, except Tolleshunt is spelled incorrectly on one of them. None of these logs prove Nevill called because they are copies of West's log - from JEREMY'S call. Had they been the Bonnet log, it might have been more interesting!! 

So you still maintain that Jeremy left WHF for Goldhanger in less than 10 minutes ?

[lookout]

ALL emergency calls are taped usually,so where is that proof,the tapes ?

[Caroline]

ALL emergency calls are taped usually,so where is that proof,the tapes ?

Jeremy didn't call the emergency number!

[nugnug]

geting back to the orignal topic does anybody else think its a bit unusaul that jeremy used exactly the same words in a conversion with to diffrent people.

[Caroline]

geting back to the orignal topic does anybody else think its a bit unusaul that jeremy used exactly the same words in a conversion with to diffrent people.

No.

[Jane]

ALL emergency calls are taped usually,so where is that proof,the tapes ?

If Jeremy had MADE an emergency call, they'd have been there, which also suggests that the call Neville didn't make to the police was a non emergency call.

[lookout]

Jeremy didn't call the emergency number!

Neville did.

[nugnug]

No.

how likely is it that somone is going to use iexactly the same sentence when talking to  diffrent people.