1) Even though it was getting dark out and Jeremy was in the kitchen with the lights on (lighting reflects off windows and makes it more difficult to see outdoors when it is getting dark) he somehow managed to detect rabbits at quite a distance and though Jeremy was against shooting animals and was not known to ever have shot any animals before, he decided to get his gun to shoot at the rabbits instead of running out and chasing them away.
2) Even though the last known user of the gun put it away with the moderator and scope attached and all witnesses except Jeremy say Nevill had no reason to remove the scope and moderator and would not have done so he did so and thus Jeremy found the gun without the scope and moderator.
3) Jeremy decided there wasn’t enough time to attach the moderator and scope because the rabbits might leave so didn’t bother to take them. He grabbed a full or near full box of ammo and the gun, removed the magazine from the gun and set the gun down near the rear door. Instead of loading the magazine there he returned to the kitchen, dumped out the bullets near the phone and loaded the magazine where Sheila was nearby so she had a full view of what he was doing. Then he went back to the gun, inserted the magazine, chambered a round and went out to shoot the rabbits but they were gone already.
4) Instead of putting the gun away he removed the magazine, removed the round that had been in the chamber and put it back in the magazine and left the gun and loaded magazine on the table or the settle depending upon which account of his you go by. June and Nevill fail to put the gun and loaded magazine away or bullets spilled by the phone away even though the grandkids were over and June subsequently used the phone that the bullets were next to.
5) Even though Sheila was over sedated thus tired and going to bed early, had never been violent towards anyone during an episode and had never before had an episode except when she stopped her medication, and despite being on her medication she had an episode late at night and to have become violent.
6) Sheila had to picked up the gun and figured out how to operate the weapon including how to insert the magazine and figured out both that she needed to manually chamber the first round and how to chamber it though she never saw anyone use a semi-auto before and at most saw people use shotguns which would not even mean she would know how to load and use a shotgun let along a gun that operates differently.
7) Sheila had to have gone to the closet to get the moderator out and attached it on her own.
Sheila had to have woken up her parents raging with a gun and June had to have stayed in bed while Nevill decided to deal with the situation.
9) Sheila for some reason had to have decided not to kill her parents right away but instead decided to run around with the gun ranting and to somehow give Nevill at least several minutes alone in the kitchen
10) Nevill had to have been unable to calm her down like he always had been able to do in the past, had to have decided not to arm himself with any of the guns, knives or other weapons available in the kitchen, had to have decided not to try to disarm her himself even though she would not know she needed to chamber a round let alone how and though he was stronger than her or Jeremy he decided to have Jeremy come to disarm her though Jeremy would make things worse because she didn’t get along with him and even though Jeremy had an answering machine and his phone was far from his bedroom so his answering machine would pick up even if he actually managed to wake up. Nevill had to have decided time was not of the essence and that there would be time for Jeremy to arrive and find a way in before Sheila did anything.
11) Somehow Jeremy had to have woken up fast enough to run down to his phone and pick it up before it went to his answering machine
12) After receiving the call from Nevill Jeremy decided not to rushing over or calling 999 like a rational person in his place would do but instead decided to do nothing at first, then called Julie and finally to call police but instead of dialing 999 to look up 2 different stations. Then he lied to police and claimed he called them right away though he actually called Julie first despite it not making any sense.
13) Sheila had to have decided not to kill Nevill upon discovering him on the phone but instead chose to hang up the phone and leave it off the hook so no one could call. Nevill had to have decided not to take advantage of her being so close with only 1 hand on the gun (thus a golden opportunity to disarm her) and then she had to have marched him upstairs because she wanted to kill her parents together in the same room.
14) After shooting them in the bedroom they went into the kitchen where Sheila had to have managed to beat Nevill unconscious without without injuring her feet on the glass on the kitchen floor and had to have been wearing gloves while doing so because unless she was wearing gloves her prints would have been in the blood on the rifle and her hand would have been wounded when the stock broke.
15) After shooting Nevill in the kitchen Sheila had to have decided to stop using the ammo supply in the kitchen and though 30 bullets remained there to go to the closet to get 5-7 additional rounds to use.
16) After killing everyone Sheila had to have hidden the bloody gloves for no rational reason and police either never found them or for no rational reason concealed the fact they found them.
17) After that Sheila had to have removed the moderator and put it back in the closet.
18) Sheila had to have either have miraculously not gotten any victim blood impact spatter blood on her clothing or after murdering everyone she changed her clothing for no rational reason, hid her clothing for no rational reason and police either failed to find such
clothing or found it but concealed the fact they found it.
19) Sheila had to have fired the first shot into her neck while seated propped against something holding the gun virtually level at her neck at non-contact range though her arms would be too short to hold the gun in such manner.
20) Within seconds of firing the first shot Sheila had to have fired the second shot while seated propped up against something and then after the fatal shot was delivered to have somehow managed not to die instantly and instead to have miraculously survived long enough to move her body flat and place the gun across her body
21) Sheila had to have miraculously survived her fatal shot long for a pool of blood to form after she lied down and to have placed the bible in such pool of blood.
22) Either:
A) The police lab managed to somehow misidentify that the blood in the moderator was June and Nevill’s mixed (though there was no realistic way that could happen) and the lab concealed the finding of Sheila’s blood in the rifle barrel
or
B) the family, police and the lab had to have conspired to plant blood/paint in/on the moderator and to have scratched the mantle with the moderator and to have concealed finding Sheila’s blood in the rifle barrel.
23) Sheila had to have shot herself miraculously without any GSR depositing on her gown and hands or the lab botched the testing of her swabs and her gown and failed to detect GSR that was present.
24) Sheila had to have washed her hands extremely well after murdering everyone else to eliminate visible lead marks that would have been on her hand from loading bullets into the murder weapon’s magazine.
25) Julie had to have lied about everything and to have made up the hitman story knowing that MM didn’t do it so knowing he would most likely have an alibi and thus could refute the allegations despite knowing that Jeremy had no alibi so she had no need for a hitman story and could have just made up the claim Jeremy told her he did it personally if she wanted to make up lies.
26) Jeremy had to have lied to police about Sheila firing all weapons in the house, forgot that he could enter through the window when they asked if there was a way in, forgot there was a spare key kept in an outbuilding when he was asked if there was a spare key and to have calmly decided to chat instead of trying to go inside or to try to get police to go inside to check on his family.
27) Jeremy had to have lied for no reason about the unbroken kitchen being a spare and the bedroom phone had to have replaced the kitchen phone for no rational reason since it wasn’t broken.
All of these unlikely things had to happen in order for Jeremy to be innocent. Not 1 unlikely thing but a whole series of unlikely things. What is the statistical chance of all these things happening let alone the chance of all these things happening without any evidence to prove they happened?
