Neville & Jeremy. The last blazing row ?

[lookout]

He can't be a suspect in this case.

How do you know ?

[Jan]

Have you ever had the feeling that you're missing out? I wish someone would explain where all this information from the last 20 threads or so is emanating from.

Its a book by Peter Thomas Healey Rough Justice  - I REPEAT he was not accusing Jimmy of the murders - but he felt the Jury were not given the  full picture of the family . I guess he was self published and any money made from the book ( if any ) was going to charity. It is quite useful though because there are some good summaries at the end of newspaper reports and the how the justice system disclosure etc has changed over the years. He believes that there was non - disclosure that meant JB did not have a fair trial .Just his opinion he is not a legal expert or anything like that .

[Caroline]

How do you know ?

I knew you would ask  Beeeeeeeecause ......... Jeremy said his father phoned him and told him "Sheila, has gone crazy, she's got the gun"

[Jane]

How do you know ?

Lookout, why are you so keen to make him a suspect?

[Alias]

I knew you would ask  Beeeeeeeecause ......... Jeremy said his father phoned him and told him "Sheila, has gone crazy, she's got the gun"

Buuuuut, he could have pretended to be Nevill on the phone..... 

[lookout]

I knew you would ask  Beeeeeeeecause ......... Jeremy said his father phoned him and told him "Sheila, has gone crazy, she's got the gun"

It might NOT have been his father on the phone though. A man the same age as his father would sound pretty well the same on the phone.

[Caroline]

Buuuuut, he could have pretended to be Nevill on the phone..... 

Would you be fooled by someone pretending to be your father? And for what reason would he have to kill two small sleeping children? If he had a beef with Nevill, I very much doubt he would wait until Sheila and her children were there. He sounds like the kind of person who is reactionary and does things on the spur - not sneak into someone's house in the dead of night.

[Caroline]

It might NOT have been his father on the phone though. A man the same age as his father would sound pretty well the same on the phone.

So all elderly men sound the same? I would know my dads voice in a thousand!

[lookout]

Lookout, why are you so keen to make him a suspect?

Because I've never believed that Sheila took her own life.

[Caroline]

Because I've never believed that Sheila took her own life.

She didn't 

[Jane]

Would you be fooled by someone pretending to be your father? And for what reason would he have to kill two small sleeping children? If he had a beef with Nevill, I very much doubt he would wait until Sheila and her children were there. He sounds like the kind of person who is reactionary and does things on the spur - not sneak into someone's house in the dead of night.

Caroline, there was nothing duplicitous about him. He didn't take time out to consider what would be his best move. He acted quite spontaneously and as I said, would NEVER have skulked around in the dark. He'd have blasted them in full daylight had he felt justified. Neither would he have attacked those who hadn't, in some way, offended him.

[Alias]

Would you be fooled by someone pretending to be your father? And for what reason would he have to kill two small sleeping children? If he had a beef with Nevill, I very much doubt he would wait until Sheila and her children were there. He sounds like the kind of person who is reactionary and does things on the spur - not sneak into someone's house in the dead of night.

I happen to have an extreme memory for voices, so no, I wouldn´t be fooled. I don´t know how Jeremy´s voice recognition capacity is. He claims he was woken up, probably confused, conversation very short.

I don´t seriously think this happened, but nothing is impossible, and I am always looking for that missing piece. To me the case is not solved.

[lookout]

Would you be fooled by someone pretending to be your father? And for what reason would he have to kill two small sleeping children? If he had a beef with Nevill, I very much doubt he would wait until Sheila and her children were there. He sounds like the kind of person who is reactionary and does things on the spur - not sneak into someone's house in the dead of night.

My late husband and his brother sounded identical on the phone. My daughters' friends' husband sounds like my brother.
If the guy can kill,by shooting his wife,and nearly killing his own child into the bargain,then he's got no qualms about shooting dead someone else's wife and children.
There's every possibility that he HADN'T known that Sheila and the twins were there.

[Jane]

Because I've never believed that Sheila took her own life.

Surely you can't mean that ANYONE other than Jeremy is responsible!!!

[Caroline]

Caroline, there was nothing duplicitous about him. He didn't take time out to consider what would be his best move. He acted quite spontaneously and as I said, would NEVER have skulked around in the dark. He'd have blasted them in full daylight had he felt justified. Neither would he have attacked those who hadn't, in some way, offended him.

That's how he sounds to me too - a hothead.