The murder of 14 year-old schoolgirl Jodi Jones near Edinburgh on 30 June 2003

[nugnug]

we chalenged you to provide proof of this and yourefused to do so why was that.

[Lithium]

we chalenged you to provide proof of this and yourefused to do so why was that.

No, you did.

If Sandra denies it, I'll be happy to prove her a liar.

[nugnug]

I don't want anyone to take a lie detector. I asked Sandra (who obviously believes they work) if she would take one regarding accusing Jodi's family of incest. Which she has avoided answering in the past.

we repeatedly challenged you to provide proof of this witch you cliamed you had and you refused to do so why is that.

[nugnug]

No, you did.

If Sandra denies it, I'll be happy to prove her a liar.

why cant you do that now.

[Lithium]

Who's "we"? only you challenged me

even Gordo was telling me not to expose her


there would be no point in me doing it right now as I wouldn't be proving anyone a liar, as she hasn't publicly confirmed nor denied it...

If she denies in here that she ever accused the Jones family of incest, I will expose her as a liar.

[nugnug]

well not everybody has time to deny allegations as quickly as you choose to make them up im afraid.

[guest154]

I think that everyone knows SL will never publicly deny it.

[Lithium]

well not everybody has time to deny allegations as quickly as you choose to make them up im afraid.

This sentence makes absolutely no sense.

[nugnug]

well i think most people can understand what im saying.

[Lugg]

Who's "we"? only you challenged me

even Gordo was telling me not to expose her


there would be no point in me doing it right now as I wouldn't be proving anyone a liar, as she hasn't publicly confirmed nor denied it...

If she denies in here that she ever accused the Jones family of racism, I will expose her as a liar.

I thought you said she accused the family of incest?

I don't want anyone to take a lie detector. I asked Sandra (who obviously believes they work) if she would take one regarding accusing Jodi's family of incest. Which she has avoided answering in the past.

[nugnug]

well hes makeing up as he goes along i think.

[Lithium]

lol, nice try nugnug. My phone autocorrects certain words sometimes. 'Racism' was obviously not the intended word as everyone involved in the case is white.

[OnceSaid]

"The public would have been prevented from knowing the identity of a killer such as Luke Mitchell had the plans to extend the bar on the identification of an accused from under 16 to under 18 been in place at the time of his conviction".

I don't think there was many a person in Scotland and beyond who hadn't heard of Luke Mitchell before his conviction.
 
Personally, I don't think anyone should be named until after the trial regardless of age.  How are the powers that be going to implement this?

http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/home-news/new-proposal-to-let-young-killers-remain-anonymous.20151891

[nugnug]

i doubt very much weather they would of got a conviction without the media coverage and i think the police knew that.

[jim ignatowski]

"The public would have been prevented from knowing the identity of a killer such as Luke Mitchell had the plans to extend the bar on the identification of an accused from under 16 to under 18 been in place at the time of his conviction".

I don't think there was many a person in Scotland and beyond who hadn't heard of Luke Mitchell before his conviction.
 
Personally, I don't think anyone should be named until after the trial regardless of age.  How are the powers that be going to implement this?

http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/home-news/new-proposal-to-let-young-killers-remain-anonymous.20151891

I'm sorry but I can't agree with that at all
For example, quite often the publication of a Defendant's name following him/her being charged with an offence prompts other, additional witnesses to come forward.
Say that in a serious rape case, a person is charged with a single offence of rape but, in fact, he is a serial rapist, the naming him as the alleged rapist in that one case often prompts other females who have been raped to come forward
If your proposal was implemented, that situation couldn't arise !
jim