The murder of 14 year-old schoolgirl Jodi Jones near Edinburgh on 30 June 2003

[OnceSaid]

Thanks Sandra, (I'm dropping the L when addressing you), I totally understand where your coming from.

[OnceSaid]

Sorry but I am having a terrible time posting links.  Hope this one works 

http://caseblog.wronglyaccusedperson.org.uk/luke-mitchell-is-innocent/

[nugnug]

considring the case was at the sccrc  takeing a lie detector test and failing could be a big risk it could affect an appeal it would certanly affect a retrial but luke and corrine still wanted to take anyway witch i think says a lot.

[wichfinder]

well yes it proves hes guilty i mean who would take such at test if they weren't in league with Satan and he wasn't helping them.

[nugnug]

maybe the scotish sun editors would like to take a polygraph about there relationship with prosecutor in this case.

[OnceSaid]

well yes it proves hes guilty i mean who would take such at test if they weren't in league with Satan and he wasn't helping them.

If the need arose, would you take a polygraph test to prove your innocence?

[nugnug]

i think its rather significant that both luke and corrine took the tests so its a double pass.

[Buddy]

i think its rather significant that both luke and corrine took the tests so its a double pass.

Good point Nugs.

[rhodes]

Good point Nugs.

They were lucky.

[Buster2]

how do you mean lucky?

[nugnug]

They were lucky.

they would have to be very lucky.

[nugnug]

i dont think this can all just be put down to luck.

[OnceSaid]

They were lucky.

Are you saing that both Luke Mitchell and his mother wanting to take a polygraph, actually doing it and both passing with different questions was down to being lucky?  Since 30th June 2003 this family was struck a major blow and it has been 9 years of bad luck ever since, but it seems out of all this devastation you are suggesting that luck was on their side the day they sat the individual polygraph tests.  Did you actually think things through before you left that comment?

[gordo30]

Its hard for people with little insight to come up with anything other than the profound "they were lucky" comment as that would take too much thought to actually come up with any real reason behind it.

[nugnug]

so if it was just the case that were lucky we must asume that colin stagg was lucky as well and that adrian prout was just unlucky.