Jeremy's double alibi attempt. Would it have made a difference. ?

[Jane]

Is that why he broke into the caravan site ?

Adam, you have to understand that each individual (act) is an idiomatic breach of the syntax of the species.

[nugnug]

Did you not read the thread post ?

yes theres nothing there that says he was trying to create do you actully no what an albi is adam

its being somewhere else at the time the crime happened.

Jeremy clearly never created an albi for then.

[Adam]

Jeremy did try to create an alibi - Neville.

Ringing his cottage from WHF. Then claiming he was at home when Neville rang.

Being at home and half dressed when the police pick him up enhances that alibi. But the police refused.

[lookout]

 Half dressed ? He'd just got out of bed,,,unless you go to bed fully clothed ?

[Jan]

its like groundhog day again.

Why would JB do all that planning and try and create the most difficult alibi ever ( the phone call )  so one minute he is the most crafty and planning murderer ever - and the next the guilters are saying its his most stupid mistake?


and yet he is stupid enough to use a silencer ( when there was no need) 
Stupid enough to tell his girlfriend his plans?

I do not understand that people can not see the basics before their eyes - it does not make any sense .

He was only 24 and busy doing 14 hours a day on the farm where would he have had the energy and intelligence to plan the most evil  and cunning murder ever - but was actually the most stupid?

[lookout]

 I wouldn't mind,,but there was NO planning whatsoever,,and certainly NO notion that this very sad event was going to happen.   I won't have it any other way other than it was a domestic situation which went horribly wrong,,and I will keep supporting Jeremy on this however long it takes,,,because I know in my own heart that it wasn't him who carried out this awful crime.

[Adam]

its like groundhog day again.

Why would JB do all that planning and try and create the most difficult alibi ever ( the phone call )  so one minute he is the most crafty and planning murderer ever - and the next the guilters are saying its his most stupid mistake?


and yet he is stupid enough to use a silencer ( when there was no need) 
Stupid enough to tell his girlfriend his plans?

I do not understand that people can not see the basics before their eyes - it does not make any sense .

He was only 24 and busy doing 14 hours a day on the farm where would he have had the energy and intelligence to plan the most evil  and cunning murder ever - but was actually the most stupid?

What was his other option ?

Find the bodies the following morning.

Think about it.

Silencer - well he was doing a 2.00am execution.

[Adam]

I wouldn't mind,,but there was NO planning whatsoever,,and certainly NO notion that this very sad event was going to happen.   I won't have it any other way other than it was a domestic situation which went horribly wrong,,and I will keep supporting Jeremy on this however long it takes,,,because I know in my own heart that it wasn't him who carried out this awful crime.

That's the spirit.

Free Jeremy.

[nugnug]

What was his other option ?

Find the bodies the following morning.

Think about it.

Silencer - well he was doing a 2.00am execution.

finding the bodys wouldn't automatically make him a suspect

and all he would of had to do is call barabra willson say hed knocked and couldn't get an answer and send her down to find the bodys.

[lookout]

 It's not easy when you're telling the truth,Adam. As has been proven.

 I know what my own gut feeling is,,and I'm standing by that.

 It's about time that you looked long and hard into this case and use your own initiative instead of taking the easy way out just by keeping on saying " guilty ". I'm damn glad your not a jury member if I was on trial,,and that goes for others like you. 

[nugnug]

all he had to do if he was killer is go the next day knock and leave when nobody replied.

then waste time ringing people up asking if they had seen his father.

[maggie]

all he had to do if he was killer is go the next day knock and leave when nobody replied.

then waste time ringing people up asking if they had seen his father.

He could have raised the alarm that all was strangely quiet, found one of the farmworkers and they could have both climbed through the window.  think that is far more convincing than a phone call no one can prove happened.

[lookout]

Unless it would have been said that Jeremy had come straight out of the farmhouse.

[nugnug]

He could have raised the alarm that all was strangely quiet, found one of the farmworkers and they could have both climbed through the window.  think that is far more convincing than a phone call no one can prove happened.

and then he would have an independent witness to confirm his story.

[maggie]

Unless it would have been said that Jeremy had come straight out of the farmhouse.

Not if he took someone in with him in with him??