What REALLY Convinces You That Jeremy Is Innocent/Guilty?

[Jane]

Why would Jeremy  pick up Sheila to take her into another room ?

How could she have got the gun, massacred the children she was attached to, brutally beaten the father she was very attached to, & killed herself if she was in bed ?

There is no guarantee Sheila would wake up in the 30 seconds it would take to pick her up and take her a few yards. If she did start to wake she would not have a clue what was happening.

How the HELL would we know. YOU'RE the one who suggests these things. Go answer. On second thoughts..........................................

[Alias]

Sheila was mentally ill. Sometimes she saw the people closest to her as the Devil or the Devil´s childrem. What part of mentally ill don´t you get? Why is this so easily dismissed by nons?

It is not logical that Jeremy would have taken Sheila into the main bedroom, it was filled with blood, and June lay dead on the floor smeared in blood. If I step into your crazy scenario for a minute, he would more likely have carried her to the corridor.

[Adam]

Adam's scenario: Jeremy, with gun, goes in to Sheila's room. Puts gun down, picks up Sheila. Realizes he can't pick gun up. Puts Sheila back on bed. Picks up gun but hasn't got Sheila. Asks Sheila to hold the gun while he carries her into her parents room to shoot her. YEH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Who mentioned a gun ?

Sheila would have been shot after June & Neville.  The gun left in the main bedroom while Jeremy went to get Sheila.

[Alias]

I would like to hear scipio´s take on the state of Sheila´s bed. Can´t deal with your fantasies anymore, Adam, sorry.

[Adam]

I have established something important today.

That Jeremy could have carried an asleep Sheila into the main bedroom. Fact.

[Alias]

I have established something important today.

That Jeremy could have carried an asleep Sheila into the main bedroom. Fact.

And I repeat: bullshit.

[lookout]

I thought Sheilas bed had not been slept in ?

It was August, so certainly the time when people would lay on, rather than in a bed. Meaning it was even easier for Jeremy to pick her up.

Jeremy may have made the bed himself before leaving WHF. To make it look like Sheila had not been to bed.

It hadn't been slept in,,and I didn't say it had been. Read it again. I've just said it was cool for the time of the year,,11c,that's all it was,and when you're supposed to be tired,,it feels all the damn colder.

So Jeremy decides to start making beds ? Sheesh,,I don't know any " killer " who's stopped in his tracks and said to himself " I must make that bed ".Bloody hell,Adam.

[susan]

Adam I have lost my way why would Jeremy wish to make it look that Sheila had not slept by making her bed yet he picked her up whilst asleep carried her to another room and shot her HELP

[Adam]

Adam I have lost my way why would Jeremy wish to make it look that Sheila had not slept by making her bed yet he picked her up whilst asleep carried her to another room and shot her HELP

Use you're loaf. Or read my other posts on this thread.

He can't shoot Sheila in her bed. She has to out of bed to make it look like she has been charging around with the rifle. So Jeremy could have spent 30 seconds carrying a small, asleep Sheila a few yards to where most of the bullets were fired.

He could have made the bed afterwards to make it look like Sheila had been up all night in a crazy rage.

[Jane]

I have established something important today.

That Jeremy could have carried an asleep Sheila into the main bedroom. Fact.

It fits well with the rest of the juvenile, self opinionated garbage you post, Adam. MORE BULLSHIT.

[grahameb]

Use you're loaf. Or read my other posts on this thread.

He can't shoot Sheila in her bed. She has to out of bed to make it look like she has been charging around with the rifle. So Jeremy could have spent 30 seconds carrying a small Sheila a few yards to where most of the bullets were fired.

He could have made the bed afterwards to make it look like Sheila had been up all night in a crazy rage.

In other words so she would look like she did when she was found, right? So what you are suggesting is that Jeremy put her into the position she was found in order to make it look like she had done it, right? So if she had been put into the position so that it looked like she did it how would you know that it was Jeremy and not Sheila if it was made to look right?

[Jan]

I have established something important today.

That Jeremy could have carried an asleep Sheila into the main bedroom. Fact.

Then I have established something as well - he could have been asleep at home .FACT!

I know which one is more likely


You have got to get facts and scenarios clear in your mind. I could have come and knocked on your door today -FACT
 Just because I could have done it - it does not make it true

[Jan]

Use you're loaf. Or read my other posts on this thread.

He can't shoot Sheila in her bed. She has to out of bed to make it look like she has been charging around with the rifle. So Jeremy could have spent 30 seconds carrying a small, asleep Sheila a few yards to where most of the bullets were fired.

He could have made the bed afterwards to make it look like Sheila had been up all night in a crazy rage.

Adam you are just trying to wind us up. You can not be serious, good try though
.

[Caroline]

To make it look like Sheila had been up all night.

What difference would that make?

[lookout]

 It didn't happen that way,Adam-----------FACT.