What REALLY Convinces You That Jeremy Is Innocent/Guilty?

[Alias]

The thing is that it is very difficult to come up with something plausible when it comes to where Sheila was during the shootings (yelling, screaming, dogs barking, commotion, a lot of noise) and how the shots to Sheila were delivered.
What nons come up with is never satisfactory and sometimes, like in this case, simply absurd.

[grahameb]

I wonder why it's so important to you that Sheila was asleep. Perhaps if you share it with us it will prevent you from behaving like an irritating child.

Because it is vital in order to fit in with his scenario.

[Alias]

Adam, isn´t it time for your nappie? 

[Adam]

I am pleased that I have discovered another possible way Jeremy killed Sheila.

Jeremys supporters claim Sheilas bed was not slept in. If she was laying on top of the bed, it would then be even easier for Jeremy to pick her up without waking her.

Oh dear.

[Jane]

Adam, isn´t it time for your nappie? 

Someone stick a dummy in his mouth, PLEEEEEEZE

[Adam]

I wonder why it's so important to you that Sheila was asleep. Perhaps if you share it with us it will prevent you from behaving like an irritating child.

[Adam]

Yes it is.

There are lots of ways Sheila ended up into the far corner of the bedroom.

Carried.

She woke & went into her parents bedroom. Cowering in the corner when seeing a gun man enter the room.
 
She was taken there after brother Jeremy took her there.


Either way Sheila would not have known what was happening, so not putting up a fight.

[Alias]

I am pleased that I have discovered another possible way Jeremy killed Sheila.

Jeremys supporters claim Sheilas bed was not slept in. If she was laying on top of the bed, it would then be even easier for Jeremy to pick her up without waking her.

Oh dear.

The only thing you have managed to prove is that, as I said in a previous post, men have unrealistically high opinions of themselves and their "brilliance". It is quite hard to stomach! 

[Jane]

The only thing you have managed to prove is that, as I said in a previous post, men have unrealistically high opinions of themselves and their "brilliance". It is quite hard to stomach! 

Don't you mean what THEY think of as being brilliant?

[Adam]

The thing is that it is very difficult to come up with something plausible when it comes to where Sheila was during the shootings (yelling, screaming, dogs barking, commotion, a lot of noise) and how the shots to Sheila were delivered.
What nons come up with is never satisfactory and sometimes, like in this case, simply absurd.

The twins were asleep when shot. June was shot with her head on the pillow. Neville shot in the bedroom 4 times. A silencer attached. What screaming & yelling ?

The fight was in another part of a big house. So with Sheilas bedroom door shut she may not have heard the fight.

But as I said she may have woken & cowered in the corner of the bedroom when she saw a gunman.

[grahameb]

I am pleased that I have discovered another possible way Jeremy killed Sheila.

Jeremys supporters claim Sheilas bed was not slept in. If she was laying on top of the bed, it would then be even easier for Jeremy to pick her up without waking her.

Oh dear.

Yes. Oh dear. It means that she was not asleep.

[grahameb]

The twins were asleep when shot. June was shot with her head on the pillow. Neville shot in the bedroom 4 times. A silencer attached. What screaming & yelling ?

The fight was in another part of a big house. So with Sheilas bedroom door shut she may not have heard the fight.

But as I said she may have woken & cowered in the corner of the bedroom when she saw a gunman.

Whoa there. You've just contradicted your original scenario. For in that you said he's been shot in the back and then Jeremy chased after him. I told you then that he was not shot in the back but in the arm. She didn't believe me. But now that NCIS boy has turned up suddenly that one shot in the back has become 4 shots? Oh dear, your scenario is gradually being broken down by your fellow guilters.

[lookout]

I am pleased that I have discovered another possible way Jeremy killed Sheila.

Jeremys supporters claim Sheilas bed was not slept in. If she was laying on top of the bed, it would then be even easier for Jeremy to pick her up without waking her.

Oh dear.

It was quite cool that night too,,so it doesn't make sense not being under the covers. Afterall,,there was even a pair of bedsocks lying around which would indicate that it wasn't exactly roasting hot.

Why get under the covers and just lie there if you're not tired---------as Sheila wasn't !

[Adam]

Whoa there. You've just contradicted your original scenario. For in that you said he's been shot in the back and then Jeremy chased after him. I told you then that he was not shot in the back but in the arm. She didn't believe me. But now that NCIS boy has turned up suddenly that one shot in the back has become 4 shots? Oh dear, your scenario is gradually being broken down by your fellow guilters.

I do not understand.

Are you saying Neville was not shot 4 times in the bedroom ?

[Alias]

It was quite cool that night too,,so it doesn't make sense not being under the covers. Afterall,,there was even a pair of bedsocks lying around which would indicate that it wasn't exactly roasting hot.

Why get under the covers and just lie there if you're not tired---------as Sheila wasn't !

I agree about Sheila not covering up in bed - which also make it possible that she was wearing her day-clothes, simply hadn´g gone to bed; but I don´t think those socks are bedsocks - just socks thrown  on the floor. I think we discussed this earlier.