Sheila's Canvas Shoes OR Neville's Slipper?

[Jane]

It was a rhetorical question anyway. But there MUST be more to it!!

Caroline, like so much more about this case, you can take your choice between between mucking fuddle and myth.

[Caroline R]

Thanks Lookout!!

[susan]

well now it seems the twin room was the usual room for June and Ralph and AE thought Sheila was in the double as that is where her body was found but AE did not know that they had changed rooms.

[HMEssex]

So the slipper is not the same as Sheila's shoes as the shoes were by the wardrobe?  Are there any photo of these?

EP still said "You haven't seen this".

AE's statements just ramble.

Hopefully, EP have better typists these days who know how to spell (not use homonyms), and understand grammar and punctuation.  The lack of all this leads to so much confusion.  Complete dimwits.  It would be funny if it wasn't so serious!

[Caroline R]

So the slipper is not the same as Sheila's shoes as the shoes were by the wardrobe?  Are there any photo of these?

EP still said "You haven't seen this".

AE's statements just ramble.

Hopefully, EP have better typists these days who know how to spell (not use homonyms), and understand grammar and punctuation.  The lack of all this leads to so much confusion.  Complete dimwits.  It would be funny if it wasn't so serious!

These were by the wardrobe

[HMEssex]

I beg your pardon!

Same shoes/slippers 

[Caroline R]

well now it seems the twin room was the usual room for June and Ralph and AE thought Sheila was in the double as that is where her body was found but AE did not know that they had changed rooms.

Where does it say that Susan? She refers to the 'spare' room as Sheila's room and describes seeing lumps on 'the' bed in June and Neville's room. I haven't read anything that suggests they slept apart and the double room is always referred to as June and Neville's room.

[maggie]

Where does it say that Susan? She refers to the 'spare' room as Sheila's room and describes seeing lumps on 'the' bed in June and Neville's room. I haven't read anything that suggests they slept apart and the double room is always referred to as June and Neville's room.

I can go with the possibility that maybe Neville has been sleeping alone because of his back but he's a big man so would imagine the big brass bed is probably a long bed to accommodate his height.  He's be far too long and very uncomfortable in one of those single beds.
So why are his slippers in the spare room?  Unless they were moved from the main bedroom by the police but why would they be?

[Caroline R]

I can go with the possibility that maybe Neville has been sleeping alone because of his back but he's a big man so would imagine the big brass bed is probably a long bed to accommodate his height.  He's be far too long and very uncomfortable in one of those single beds.
So why are his slippers in the spare room?  Unless they were moved from the main bedroom by the police but why would they be?

Hi Maggie, the point is that AE said they were Sheila's shoes and the police took them away asking her to keep quiet about it.

[maggie]

Hi Maggie, the point is that AE said they were Sheila's shoes and the police took them away asking her to keep quiet about it.

I know but they can't have been Sheila's shoes/slippers, that's crazy.

[Caroline R]

I know but they can't have been Sheila's shoes/slippers, that's crazy.

It's only crazy because now you know what they look like - previous to seeing the picture you would have assumed they were just female shoes. Perhaps that's what we're supposed to think BUT the police saw fit to take the shoes next to the wardrobe and to say nothing. I see no other shoes next to the wardrobe and no mention of Neville's slippers being in that room. Why aren't the shoes/slippers on the evidence list? I don't know what it means either but something isn't right.

[Caroline R]

It was Jones, Miller and Cook who took the shoes/slippers on the same day as they took paint samples from the fire surround on 14th August.

[maggie]

It was Jones, Miller and Cook who took the shoes/slippers on the same day as they took paint samples from the fire surround on 14th August.

So if I was guessing Caroline, I would maybe think there was something  on Sheila's canvass shoe's the police wanted to conceal.

[Caroline R]

So if I was guessing Caroline, I would maybe think there was something  on Sheila's canvass shoe's the police wanted to conceal.

Possibly but I just can't get my head round why they didn't want anyone to know they took them and also not include them on the evidence list?

[susan]

Morning Caroline  AE's statement is a tad confusing and I am not sure which beds she is referring to but would assume it was the single bed near the door as if you look at the bedcover on the double bed it was all messed up the single bed was untouched and she says when I pulled back the cover I found bed linen (as if the bed would be made up once Sheila had left) All so confusing but then again how accurate was AE in her statement.