If Jane Tanner saw the abductor carrying off Maddie, this would have had to have occurred before 9:30pm, and would throw doubt over the claim made by another member of the tapas group who said they had gone to Apartment 5A at about 9:30pm, reporting back to the McCanns that all was quiet back at the apartment, since abductor would already have taken Maddie before such an additional check...
I am finding it hard to make any sense out of these accounts?