But you can't convict anyone on statement analysis. I just think they know they were basically wrong in leaving their children unsupervised and they're trying to overcompensate for the benefit of the twins as they grow older.
Critics argue that the technique encourages investigators to prejudge a suspect as deceptive and affirm a presumption of guilt before the interrogation process has even begun. Statement analysis in general has been criticized as "theoretically vague" with little or no empirical evidence in its favor, and SCAN in particular has been characterized as "junk science"[1] with the Skeptic's Dictionary and Skeptical Inquirer magazine[12] classifying it as a form of pseudoscience.[2]
It seems a clear case to me from observing the McCann Parents throughout this so called ordeal that they are going through that they are faking their reactions, it doesn't come across as genuine! I don't believe that Madeleine was alive after going to the lobster creche that Tuesday afternoon (1st May 2007), nobody handed her back to anyone, and nobody collected Madeleine from the creche that afternoon! Rather more astonishingly Madeleine was booked back into the lobster creche on the following morning, and back out again! This was repeated in the afternoon session of Wednesday 2nd May 2007, booked in and out! Finally according to the dodgy creche register Madeleine was booked into the lobster creche again on the Thursday morning (3rd May 2007) and back out again ! Also, in the afternoon session the creche log has Madeleine booked in there from 14.30hrs, and the fact that Kate McCann collected Madeleine from there at 17.30hrs, against her signature - what I find truly remarkable is that in her book 'Madeleine'', Kate states that upon returning to the tapas area from her run that afternoon at 5.30pm, she found Gerry and their three siblings had already started eating high tea, but this cannot possibly be true if Kate had collected Madeleine from lobster creche at 17.30hrs! Furthermore, her run along the beach would have brought her past the lobster creche where Madeleine was supposedly being looked after by the creche nanny CAT-fem. What raises a red flag for me here, is that Kate also collected the twins Amelie and Sean from the Jellyfish creche at 17.25hrs, against her signature, so how could all three siblings had already started eating high tea as she claims in her published book by the time she arrived there from her afternoon run at 5.30pm?
There is something dramatically wrong here, Kate wouldn't run past the lobster creche which she would have pass on her way to the tapas restaurant to meet up with Gerry, and collect the twins from the jellyfish creche at 17.25hrs, and then with the two kids in tow, dash all the way back down the hill to the lobster creche situated above the main Ocean Club reception to collect Madeleine and sign her out at 17.30hrs, and at one and the same time, as if by magic also be arriving back up the hill to find Gerry and their three siblings had already started eating their high tea?
Surely, you don't believe a word of what they say happened, and what must have happened on that occasion?
Madeleine wasn't even still alive by that stage, let alone that she was already eating her high tea when Kate returned to the tapas restaurant at 5.30pm from her run, or and Kate had run past the lobster creche to go and get Amelie and Sean from Jellyfish creche at 17.25hrs, and dashing all the way back down hill all the way to the lobster creche above the main Ocean club reception by 17.30hrs, and then somehow be instantaneously back up the hill to find that the three children she had collected were already there with Gerry already eating their high teas?
Either, Kate collected Amelie and Sean at 17.25hrs, and then took both of them all the way down hill to the lobster creche above the main Ocean club reception in time to collect and sign for Madeleine at 17.30hrs, or she didn't?
When she returned from her run that afternoon, she either arrived at the tapas restaurant at 5.30pm to find that Gerry, Amelie, Sean and Madeleine had already started eating high tea at that stage, or they hadn't?
Seems somewhat obvious to me that Kate couldn't have collected and signed for the collection of two kids from one creche, at 17.25hrs, and Madeleine from the other creche at 17.30 hrs, and them already being present eating high tea when she got to the tapas at 5.30pm!
How could you forget what had happened when it was the last meal that Kate and the family (supposedly including Madeleine) would ever eat together upon this earth?
