The case of Madeleine McCann

[jaymo132]

The one thing that confuses me is that the Cadaever dogs smelt death in the car that the McCanns hired 23 days before hand and no one had hired that car before them as it was new...

[Patti]

The one thing that confuses me is that the Cadaever dogs smelt death in the car that the McCanns hired 23 days before hand and no one had hired that car before them as it was new...

It confuses me too. Apparently they can smell cadaver form 100 years ago.  I admit dogs are very clever, but they can't talk. If you look at the car park video, the same dogs barks at a wall and an empty car parking space....The dog also goes round the McCann's car several times and does not bark...Can we really rely on them?   

[jaymo132]

Hi Jaymo

Not is it not. If Amaral could not solve the crime while he was in the PJ, then he certainly couldn't solve it after his disgraced dismissal.  It's a long time since I read it, to be fair. 

Patti you say disgraced dismissal? Amaral,  led the investigation until October 2007 when he was removed for claiming British police were only helping with leads provided by the McCanns.

[Patti]

Patti you say disgraced dismissal? Amaral,  led the investigation until October 2007 when he was removed for claiming British police were only helping with leads provided by the McCanns.

He wasn't dismissed for that Jaymo. He was dismissed for a cover up of his colleagues on a different case. 

[jaymo132]

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1564913/Madeleine-McCann-chief-detective-sacked.html

[Patti]

That's not the case Jaymo.  The public prosecutioner accused Amoral of covering up the attack on  Leonor Cipriano in 2007.  He was dismissed because of that if memory serves me right.   

[jaymo132]

Different papers give differing reasons for his dismissal.And having been out to Praia du Luz (golfing by the way)and spoke to people out there including ex pats and locals over 75% think Mr mcCann knows a lot more than he is letting on ,and one day he will slip up ....

[lookout]

Different papers give differing reasons for his dismissal.And having been out to Praia du Luz (golfing by the way)and spoke to people out there including ex pats and locals over 75% think Mr mcCann knows a lot more than he is letting on ,and one day he will slip up ....

Jaymo,,that's because the McCanns were put on trial by the media,both here and Portugal,,also by the public too. Much the same as in the JB case where fingers are often pointed at the wrong person.
I remember seeing the difference in answers online when that woman tried to extort money for the " disappearance " of her daughter ( who'd been purposely hidden ) Sharon Matthews,,,everyone showed sympathy towards this con-woman and compared life-styles etc etc,,,until the truth came out and you never heard another thing from the " sheep ".

[jaymo132]

Jaymo,,that's because the McCanns were put on trial by the media,both here and Portugal,,also by the public too. Much the same as in the JB case where fingers are often pointed at the wrong person.
I remember seeing the difference in answers online when that woman tried to extort money for the " disappearance " of her daughter ( who'd been purposely hidden ) Sharon Matthews,,,everyone showed sympathy towards this con-woman and compared life-styles etc etc,,,until the truth came out and you never heard another thing from the " sheep ".

Lookout the McCanns put themelves on trial both here and Portugal by leaving 3 children under 5 on there own in an appartment.If Mr McCann had not been a Mason he would have been charged,but a certain ex prime minister put a stop to that.....

[lookout]

Lookout the McCanns put themelves on trial both here and Portugal by leaving 3 children under 5 on there own in an appartment.If Mr McCann had not been a Mason he would have been charged,but a certain ex prime minister put a stop to that.....

Jaymo,,the fact that the McCanns left the children has been bandied around now for the past 5 and a half years. Nobody knows better than the parents themselves that they did wrong in leaving them and that's their punishment for the rest of their lives.
Mason or not,they cannot be charged for something that they didn't do.
Would you have the same attitude if they'd been from a sink estate.?

[jaymo132]

Jaymo,,the fact that the McCanns left the children has been bandied around now for the past 5 and a half years. Nobody knows better than the parents themselves that they did wrong in leaving them and that's their punishment for the rest of their lives.
Mason or not,they cannot be charged for something that they didn't do.
Would you have the same attitude if they'd been from a sink estate.?

I certainly would....this is not a class thing 2 adult people were found to have broken the law by leaving these children unattended. Lookout i have my opinion you have yours,from what i have seen ,heard and checked for myself i think they are very guilty....but yes lets debate it's good for the soul.

[lookout]

I certainly would....this is not a class thing 2 adult people were found to have broken the law by leaving these children unattended. Lookout i have my opinion you have yours,from what i have seen ,heard and checked for myself i think they are very guilty....but yes lets debate it's good for the soul.

Yes,Jaymo,it is good to debate and to also have opposing opinions,or there'd be no room for manoeuvre.

[nugnug]

Lookout the McCanns put themelves on trial both here and Portugal by leaving 3 children under 5 on there own in an appartment.If Mr McCann had not been a Mason he would have been charged,but a certain ex prime minister put a stop to that.....

as far as i can see there is no evidence he is a mason just a wild allegation.

i have never heard of Scottish catholic Freemason before.

[susan]

nugnug  I have never heard of a Scottish Catholic Freemason either.

[lookout]

It depends which newspaper it happens to be,,and it also depends if you believe everything you read.