Jeremy Bamber: the Prelude, the Tragedy and the Aftermath

[Caroline]

Hartley it wouldn't have made a scrap of difference how I'd worded it or even what I presently post because I get nothing but hostility in return,so what's the use ?
If this were a forum of people willing to accept an opposing view,then my posts would be in accordance with their opposition,but until then,I'll post as I'm posted to in this ridiculous tit for tat fashion.

Of course it would have made a difference, instead, you claimed it was factual (and that you KNEW it to be so) and wouldn't say where you go it from. Hartley even asked you out right if it was from the Poppy site and you refused to answer.

[Caroline]

I think if you simply said something along the lines of:

Hi guys, I've just read about this on Poppy's blog, does anybody know if there is any truth behind it?


Rather than making out that you were in possession of some sort of privileged secret information. That is how it came across, whether intentional or not. 

That is how it came across to me to and then Lookout dug her heels in when you asked her if it was from the Poppy site. I didn't even bother to look at that point because it was clearly unsubstantiated gossip.

[lookout]

Of course it would have made a difference, instead, you claimed it was factual (and that you KNEW it to be so) and wouldn't say where you go it from. Hartley even asked you out right if it was from the Poppy site and you refused to answer.

I DO know it to be true !! I DID NOT see Hartley's post asking me if it was Poppy.

[Jane]

Hartley it wouldn't have made a scrap of difference how I'd worded it or even what I presently post because I get nothing but hostility in return,so what's the use ?
If this were a forum of people willing to accept an opposing view,then my posts would be in accordance with their opposition,but until then,I'll post as I'm posted to in this ridiculous tit for tat fashion.

How do you KNOW that "it wouldn't have made a scrap of difference"? Perhaps if we knew what the source was, we'd direct any disbelief to it and you may not take it as personal.

[Jane]

I DO know it to be true !! I DID NOT see Hartley's post asking me if it was Poppy.

Well, you at least know it to be what Poppy SAID was true.

[Caroline]

I DO know it to be true !! I DID NOT see Hartley's post asking me if it was Poppy.

So, when you find out it's not, you'll ADMIT to being wrong?

[lookout]

See------you still dispute it. Ah well,where ignorance is bliss and all that. It would be a sheer waste of time if you were told anything face to face,you'd still argue that it wasn't true. I've known you to dispute what's been legally written,you've even poo-pooed that.

[Jane]

See------you still dispute it. Ah well,where ignorance is bliss and all that. It would be a sheer waste of time if you were told anything face to face,you'd still argue that it wasn't true. I've known you to dispute what's been legally written,you've even poo-pooed that.

Yet YOU are proclaiming to be true, something which has no basis in legality.

[lookout]

Yet YOU are proclaiming to be true, something which has no basis in legality.

I'm not arguing with you any more,either ask Poppy YOURSELF or ask Jeremy.

[sami]

So, when you find out it's not, you'll ADMIT to being wrong?

pigs will fly before she admits anything,caroline

[guest154]

See------you still dispute it. Ah well,where ignorance is bliss and all that. It would be a sheer waste of time if you were told anything face to face,you'd still argue that it wasn't true. I've known you to dispute what's been legally written,you've even poo-pooed that.

I think it is disputed even stronger now that the "source" of the information has been found. Poppys blog is where you also claimed that you'd read about two COLP reports, one secret ....(so secret that Poppy has apparently seen it). I don't think members here on either side believe Poppy reliable - she makes wild claims and then doesn't post anything to back them up.

pigs will fly before she admits anything,caroline

If it were found not to be true, Lookout would put the blame on Poppy. "Well I read it on her site! Ask her!" 

[lookout]

pigs will fly before she admits anything,caroline

Things like that don't happen with the truth ! On the pop again,are we ??

[sami]

I think it is disputed even stronger now that the "source" of the information has been found. Poppys blog is where you also claimed that you'd read about two COLP reports, one secret ....(so secret that Poppy has apparently seen it). I don't think members here on either side believe Poppy reliable - she makes wild claims and then doesn't post anything to back them up.

If it were found not to be true, Lookout would put the blame on Poppy. "Well I read it on her site! Ask her!" 

[lookout]

Christ,you'll have sami over-excited with all HIS support.

[Jane]

I'm not arguing with you any more,either ask Poppy YOURSELF or ask Jeremy.

I wonder how Jeremy would know what was going on in Julie's life. I wonder how Jeremy's loyal and bosom friend Poppy got to be such a good friend of Julie's husband that he'd reveal intimate details to her of any marital problems they may have been having.