Susan/Tyler, I think you're both totally correct. The more of us he can convince of Jeremy's guilt, the more certain he can allow himself to be of his guilt. There's just one problem. IMO, he's going entirely the wrong way about it and if he stopped sneering at psychology for long enough, he'd realize that using some reverse psychology might actually work. At the moment everything he says gives us cause to defend Jeremy, which is probably a little unrealistic. If he changed his approach more of us MAY concede a point or two.