Missing Fingernail of Sheila Caffell...

[grahameb]

How can nails be too long to cause an injury. Women can and do use their long nails to injure other people it is their way of fighting. Sheila Caffel's nail were certainly long enough to cause such injury to RB's arms.

[smiffy]

There was no expert opinion of worth in the submisssions that I see at all.
The foolish stupid incorrect claim that Sheila's nails were to long is obviously wrong and I am happy to stick with that.
I dare anyone to take me to court on that view....for none will..for I am right.

Sheila's nails were the correct size to cause the injuries seen on Ralphs arm and most likely June's too.

The depth of fingernail gouges is variable on many issues. Such as toughness of skin, length of nails, flexibility and strength of a particular persons nails, the pressure applied by the person inflicting, lubrication effects , angle of grip , size of person inflictings hands etc etc etc.... so excluding by specifying a tight specific range is total nonsense as any good worthy honest expert would know.

[smiffy]

I have plenty of qualifications mr john lamberton . As I am not BM , things you say of this innocent man are not relevant to myself.
Personally I find what you say about BM to be disgusting. His baby daughter died as the result of an accident...and you seem to find a perverse pleasure in tormenting him by posting nonsense about him.

how many years did you spend in jail john.
as far as I am aware BM was only in jail on remand.
He was found innocent ...of what he was accused of in a court of law.
You were found guilty of your crimes in a court of law.
the courts are far from perfect but in your case I feel happy that your conviction was perfectly sound.

[grahameb]

Expert opinion that the length of the nails were too long to have done the injury to Nevill or June's arms is accepted by both the Crown and the defence so one wonders what did in fact make the marks.

Perhaps m'Lud didn't have long polished fingernails so he wouldn't know?

[shonapugs]

Sorry everyone - did June have scratch/gouge injuries too?

[Alias]

Sorry everyone - did June have scratch/gouge injuries too?

Hi. I think one, which could be consistent with a fingernail making the gouge.

[shonapugs]

Hallo, Abs. Thank you. I'm really struggling to keep up with the forum - when did it become so spiteful and dodgy?

[Alias]

Hallo, Abs. Thank you. I'm really struggling to keep up with the forum - when did it become so spiteful and dodgy?

Hmmm, I try to stay out of it and hope it just goes away... 

[shonapugs]

I'll do the same. And who on earth is smiting Kaldin? He's always so fair - it's like punching a kitten.

[grahameb]

I know that someone had to do it, but Julie Mugford actually volunteered to identify the bodies? Even the children's? Good grief, am I the only one to find that shocking?

I find the whole thing very shocking.

[shonapugs]

Hallo, Grahame. Since I posted that, I think that I might now be shock-proof. I still believe my original conclusion, but I am very aware that I might be a million miles from the truth. This forum is scrambling my (very limited) brain.

[Alias]

I'll do the same. And who on earth is smiting Kaldin? He's always so fair - it's like punching a kitten.

You are right, I´d NEVER smite Kaldin, such a nice poster!! But are you sure Kaldin will be happy about you comparing him to a kitty cat? 

[shonapugs]

Gawd, I don't know. I've always imagined him/her looking like a cross between Inspector Barnaby and a lovely cake. With a cherry on top. I think I might have ODed on chocolate.