Julie Smerchanski Statement - 12/4/2002

[Hartley]

Julie Smerchanski Statement - 12/4/2002

[curiousessex]

Hartley

Good post.

I have not read this statement before. Makes interesting reading.

[grahameb]

What do you think was the purpose of her making this statement?

[tyler]

Thanks for putting these statements out Hartley.
I never really had an opinion on Julie before.But now I can see for myself that she is an out and out liar!

[Alias]

One word: BARF!

Muggie sure is good at minimizing her role in this rather serious fraud and wiping her criminal act off on Jeremy, who had absolutely NOTHING to do with this!!

"Jeremy would often tease me about being  a "goody two shoes" and goaded me about how I had never done anything wrong in my life. This led me to being the stronger influence with Susan. Before I met Jeremy I hadn't really done anything wrong. Jeremy did have an influence on me."

"It went in the bin or was given away." How stupid does she think people are?! Only stole things they didn't like! My ass!!
"They may have gone in the Sally Army boxes." BARF and double BARF.

What a load of BS! She sounds like a sociopath, "innocent" little Mugs. Sociopaths are quite good at never owning up to what they've done and very good at wiping their nasty acts off on others around them. I like her even less after reading this statement.
That it is from 2002 just shows that this woman hasn't changed one bit. A mature person would have owned up. She is unbelievable!

[grahameb]

One word: BARF!

Muggie sure is good at minimizing her role in this rather serious fraud and wiping her criminal act off on Jeremy, who had absolutely NOTHING to do with this!!

"Jeremy would often tease me about being  a "goody two shoes" and goaded me about how I had never done anything wrong in my life. This led me to being the stronger influence with Susan. Before I met Jeremy I hadn't really done anything wrong. Jeremy did have an influence on me."

"It went in the bin or was given away." How stupid does she think people are?! Only stole things they didn't like! My ass!!
"They may have gone in the Sally Army boxes." BARF and double BARF.

What a load of BS! She sounds like a sociopath, "innocent" little Mugs. Sociopaths are quite good at never owning up to what they've done and very good at wiping their nasty acts off on others around them. I like her even less after reading this statement.
That it is from 2002 just shows that this woman hasn't changed one bit. A mature person would have owned up. She is unbelievable!

And never really taking the responsibility of their own bad natures. "Before I met Jeremy I hadn't really done anything wrong. Jeremy did have an influence on me." haha.

[grahameb]

Strange thing is, the 2002 appeal judges didn't believe the bank manager's account

What did they say about it?

[chochokeira]

Where are the other 4 pages?

[Hartley]

Where are the other 4 pages?

No idea, this is all I have been able to find. Perhaps Mike may have them.

[HMEssex]

So JM and Susan Battersby were escorted to the bank by an officer - another lie.

[tyler]

So JM and Susan Battersby were escorted to the bank by an officer - another lie.

Exactly.The bank manager gives a totally different version of events.This statement proves to me that she is a liar.

[ngb1066]

So JM and Susan Battersby were escorted to the bank by an officer - another lie.

Exactly.The bank manager gives a totally different version of events.This statement proves to me that she is a liar.

If you add to that the deception about the NoW contract it is clear that the impression that was presented to the jury about this vital witness was very distorted.

[tyler]

Doesnt Julie come across as genuine and believable in her statement.That is until you read the bank managers statement whereby he gives a totally different version of events.And he had nothing at all to gain by lying!I can now see how Julie Mugford managed to pull the wool over the eyes of the jury.To think that the evidence of this blatant liar has seen a man locked up for 26 years.I really do not know how she can sleep at night!

[Alias]

Doesnt Julie come across as genuine and believable in her statement.That is until you read the bank managers statement whereby he gives a totally different version of events.And he had nothing at all to gain by lying!I can now see how Julie Mugford managed to pull the wool over the eyes of the jury.To think that the evidence of this blatant liar has seen a man locked up for 26 years.I really do not know how she can sleep at night!

I think she is a sociopath - they sleep just fine, no matter what.

[chochokeira]

So JM and Susan Battersby were escorted to the bank by an officer - another lie.

Exactly.The bank manager gives a totally different version of events.This statement proves to me that she is a liar.

If you add to that the deception about the NoW contract it is clear that the impression that was presented to the jury about this vital witness was very distorted.

Add to that the other inconsistencies in JM's account too: the hit man, the position of Sheila's body, the position of the Bible.

Why do JM's errors in respect of the position of Sheila's body and of the Bible match AE's errors in these respects?