Flaws in David1819's Sheila scenario.

[David1819]

You mean an "industrial frame"?    

How could the lab have fabricated the silencer when the blood, paint and hair were seen by others before the silencer even arrived at the lab?

You tell me, that's what you said. You should remember I did not agree with you.

[killingeve]

You tell me, that's what you said. You should remember I did not agree with you.

Are you sure I wasn't teasing and/or you misunderstood?  It makes no sense given the silencer was first examined by the lab on 13th Aug and Julie did not fess up until much later?

[David1819]

Are you sure I wasn't teasing and/or you misunderstood?

No, you were being serious.

Had you already made your evening trip to the Co-op that day?

[killingeve]

No, you were being serious.

Had you already made your evening trip to the Co-op that day?

If you think my mind was/is muddled for whatever reason(s) why bother with what I think?

[killingeve]

David as you're very familiar with all things relative are you able to upload AE's cards/notes where she first refers to the finding of the silencer.  Thanks.

[snow66!]

David as you're very familiar with all things relative are you able to upload AE's cards/notes where she first refers to the finding of the silencer.  Thanks.

Some of her notes/cards are in the archive Cutie,Mike pointed out that there is no mention of finding a silencer on 10th Aug in them.

[David1819]

David as you're very familiar with all things relative are you able to upload AE's cards/notes where she first refers to the finding of the silencer.  Thanks.

I posted it on December 15th last year. You participated in the discussion that day.

[killingeve]

Some of her notes/cards are in the archive Cutie,Mike pointed out that there is no mention of finding a silencer on 10th Aug in them.

Yes, thanks, but would like to see with own eyes.

[killingeve]

I posted it on December 15th last year. You participated in the discussion that day.

Yes and that's why I am asking you to repost. 

[snow66!]

Yes, thanks, but would like to see with own eyes.

Well why dont you just take a look? They are in the statements section under Ann Eaton.

[Adam]

Well the PGM enzyme was negative, and the AK enzyme is also found in animals, and 17 out of 20 markers means it could be half the world plus little green men on Mars.

I think it's best all round to simply say it was not Sheila's blood in the silencer and whoever put the blood in it got lucky with the blood group matching Sheila's.

Unfortunately the other  COA forensic evidence confirms Bamber is guilty.

Meaning the blood in the silencer is Sheila's. Via back spatter after Bamber shot her twice.

Even David says Sheila was shot in an area of high blood flow & it is Sheila's blood. 

Nice try.

[killingeve]

Well why dont you just take a look? They are in the statements section under Ann Eaton.

Because I can't be bothered to decipher spider scrawl when David can lay his hands on it in seconds and could if he wanted repost it. 

[snow66!]

Because I can't be bothered to decipher spider scrawl when David can lay his hands on it in seconds and could if he wanted repost it.

What do you mean Cutie,has Dave got a printed legible version?

[killingeve]

What do you mean Cutie,has Dave got a printed legible version?

Sorry I thought it was obvious.  The cards are set out over pages.  David is able to quickly identify the relevant card since he uploaded it some months ago.

[snow66!]

Sorry I thought it was obvious.  The cards are set out over pages.  David is able to quickly identify the relevant card since he uploaded it some months ago.

Ah! Got you Cutes.