Flaws in David1819's Sheila scenario.

[Rob_]

Please supply your fabrication scenario.

I don't believe a killer would put the silencer back in the cupboard complete with hair, paint and blood on it. When all he had to do was place it beside Sheila such that her blood would run over it, or just simply take it with him and chuck it in the sea.

There is no need to go into details, the silencer is easily unscrewed etc.

[snow66!]

Virtually nothing is impossible but you're being somewhat facetious when you say "put blood inside it" when you know full well the blood needs to match Sheila's groups and those doing the contaminating would need access to not only an awful lot of technical data but the blood too!

Supporters need to come up with something plausible.  Ideas such as the relatives putting their own blood in or AE wringing out Sheila's menstrual stained knickers left soaking in a bucket do not even get off the starting blocks.

Or the police giving them the blood Cutie.Quite possible,quite plausable.Then everyone's happy.Well,except for JB that is!

[killingeve]

I don't believe a killer would put the silencer back in the cupboard complete with hair, paint and blood on it. When all he had to do was place it beside Sheila such that her blood would run over it, or just simply take it with him and chuck it in the sea.

There is no need to go into details, the silencer is easily unscrewed etc.

I rather think the CCRC and CoA will need to go into details about how the blood/silencer was fabricated

[Adam]

I don't believe a killer would put the silencer back in the cupboard complete with hair, paint and blood on it. When all he had to do was place it beside Sheila such that her blood would run over it, or just simply take it with him and chuck it in the sea.

There is no need to go into details, the silencer is easily unscrewed etc.

Well the evidence is he did.

[Adam]

I don't believe a killer would put the silencer back in the cupboard complete with hair, paint and blood on it. When all he had to do was place it beside Sheila such that her blood would run over it, or just simply take it with him and chuck it in the sea.

There is no need to go into details, the silencer is easily unscrewed etc.

How would he manage that?

[Adam]

I don't believe a killer would put the silencer back in the cupboard complete with hair, paint and blood on it. When all he had to do was place it beside Sheila such that her blood would run over it, or just simply take it with him and chuck it in the sea.

There is no need to go into details, the silencer is easily unscrewed etc.

There is if you believe one piece of evidence was fabricated.

[Adam]

I don't believe a killer would put the silencer back in the cupboard complete with hair, paint and blood on it. When all he had to do was place it beside Sheila such that her blood would run over it, or just simply take it with him and chuck it in the sea.

There is no need to go into details, the silencer is easily unscrewed etc.

Please provide your fabrication scenario.

[killingeve]

Or the police giving them the blood Cutie.Quite possible,quite plausable.Then everyone's happy.Well,except for JB that is!

The police giving who the blood?  Relatives? 

[Rob_]

I rather think the CCRC and CoA will need to go into details about how the blood/silencer was fabricated

Yes I hope they would, it should be easy to prove if the blood was in the silencer due to back spatter or some other means. Depending on what records are available of where the blood was actually found in the silencer.

[Rob_]

How would he manage that?

Well if he can't find a suitable spot he chucks it in the sea while cycling back to his cottage.

[Adam]

Well if he can't find a suitable spot he chucks it in the sea while cycling back to his cottage.

I agree he would not be able to.

Well the evidence is he put the silencer in it's usual place. Away from the crime scene.

[Rob_]

Please provide your fabrication scenario.

I need to know exactly where in the silencer the blood was found, I think we will find back spatter does not explain the distribution of blood in the silencer?

[Rob_]

I agree he would not be able to.

Well the evidence is he put the silencer in it's usual place. Away from the crime scene.

If guilty I bet JB at trial was scratching his head thinking how did that dam silencer get out of the sea and back into the cupboard! 

[David1819]

You are in no postion to talk about the states of minds of others when you dream up absurd theories about AE wringing out Sheila's menstrual stained knickers, found soaking in a bucket, into the silencer

Absurd theories? like June walking around with two bullets in her brains? 

PS: Please share your theory on how it was fabricated. You admitted last January you are the person below.

[killingeve]

Absurd theories? like June walking around with two bullets in her brains? 

PS: Please share your theory on how it was fabricated. You admitted last January you are the person below.

The difference between you and I is that I'm happy for others to show me the errors in my thinking and I will ditch.  I put forward the theory about June in a few posts over a few weeks and quickly abandoned.   You have been banging on about the menstrual stained knickers for years and even when faced with the scientific evidence to the contrary you refuse to give it up because you have no other viable explanation for the blood evidence if not as the prosecution claim.