Flaws in David1819's Sheila scenario.

[Adam]

They did five officers checked the cupboard.

Anyway I have a question for you why is it that Nevil does not bleed and Sheila does? She would have fallen back in seconds, and I don't consider the neck / throat anywhere near as likely to produce back spatter as a head shot would?

Nevill did bleed. In the kitchen.

[Adam]

They did five officers checked the cupboard.

Anyway I have a question for you why is it that Nevil does not bleed and Sheila does? She would have fallen back in seconds, and I don't consider the neck / throat anywhere near as likely to produce back spatter as a head shot would?

You are in the minority there. David agrees Sheila was shot in an area of high blood flow.

[Rob_]

You are in the minority there. David agrees Sheila was shot in an area of high blood flow.

That's all JB had to do, leave the silencer in a area where Sheila's blood would get on it. Months and months of planning and he puts it in the cupboard, then goes on holiday for it to be discovered.

Sounds plausible 

[lookout]

A silencer was found under the parents bed originally----so who put it in the cupboard ?

[Adam]

That's all JB had to do, leave the silencer in a area where Sheila's blood would get on it. Months and months of planning and he puts it in the cupboard, then goes on holiday for it to be discovered.

Sounds plausible 

Where could he leave the silencer where Sheila's blood would get deep inside the baffles?

Doubtful Bamber was aware of back spatter or that he even knew beforehand the rifle with silencer was too long for Sheila.

[Adam]

That's all JB had to do, leave the silencer in a area where Sheila's blood would get on it. Months and months of planning and he puts it in the cupboard, then goes on holiday for it to be discovered.

Sounds plausible 

Both guilters & supporters agree he went on holiday soon after the massacre.

Believing the police had finished at WHF & the relatives had accepted his version.

[Adam]

That's all JB had to do, leave the silencer in a area where Sheila's blood would get on it. Months and months of planning and he puts it in the cupboard, then goes on holiday for it to be discovered.

Sounds plausible 

Putting something back in it's usual place.

What is the world coming to?

[Adam]

A silencer was found under the parents bed originally----so who put it in the cupboard ?

 

[Rob_]

Where could he leave the silencer where Sheila's blood would get deep inside the baffles?

Doubtful Bamber was aware of back spatter or that he even knew beforehand the rifle with silencer was too long for Sheila.

No knowledge of back spatter required, does back spatter explain where the blood was actually found within the silencer I don't think so? perhaps you can help me?

As for leaving the silencer where it can become covered with Sheila's blood, if he cannot find a suitable spot he just takes the silencer with him he and chucks it in the sea he does not put it in the cupboard!

[Adam]

No knowledge of back spatter required, does back spatter explain where the blood was actually found within the silencer I don't think so? perhaps you can help me?

As for leaving the silencer where it can become covered with Sheila's blood, if he cannot find a suitable spot he just takes the silencer with him he and chucks it in the sea he does not put it in the cupboard!

What you think 37 years later he should have done is neither here or there.

He did what he did. Lots of reasons why.

[Adam]

No knowledge of back spatter required, does back spatter explain where the blood was actually found within the silencer I don't think so? perhaps you can help me?

As for leaving the silencer where it can become covered with Sheila's blood, if he cannot find a suitable spot he just takes the silencer with him he and chucks it in the sea he does not put it in the cupboard!

Yes.

[Adam]

Anyway the forensic evidence is it was Sheila's blood in the silencer. With 17 out of 20 markers.  Even David agrees.

The crime scene evidence shows why Sheila's blood would be in the silencer.

Supporters need to find a credible alternative explanation to Bamber shooting Sheila & creating the back spatter.

[Rob_]

Yes.

Explain then? show me a cross section through the silencer showing where the blood was found and how back spatter explains this. Don'd forget a spray travels in straight lines.

[Adam]

Explain then? show me a cross section through the silencer showing where the blood was found and how back spatter explains this. Don'd forget a spray travels in straight lines.

No. You know full well Sheila's blood inside the silencer was a result of back spatter.

Unless you can think of an alternative explanation.

[Rob_]

No. You know full well Sheila's blood inside the silencer was a result of back spatter.

Unless you can think of an alternative explanation.

You can't well no surprise, I must admit it's a bit tricky explaining how back spatter causes blood to get into two silencers at the same time, a flake in one and a pool in the other.