0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Yes Rob, but apparently the authorities have said.. “there is no documentary evidence either provided or referred to which supports the existence of a second silencer”.So, what should we make of that?
You can't 'gish gallop' on a forum, you can only really do it in conversation.On a forum there is plenty of time to go through all the points someone makes, pick out the ones you want, and then answer them with a full narrative answer, in your own time.'Gish galloping' is a technique to stop that from happening, but only works in a verbal discussion.If anything, Adam is giving you all the ammunition you need to shoot his arguments down in your own rime, and yet you don't. Instead you just accuse him of things like 'gish galloping', and chuck in a few insults. The only thing that matters is facts, information, and explanation. Responding with one sentence answers declaring someone wrong, or firing off an insult, isn't going to convince the casual passer by, who genuinely wants to know about the case. And that will water down your point of view in the eyes of that person.
Adam does 'gish gallop' I am afraid for example he must have posted a million times it 'was a silent massacre' despite MF saying the silencer made hardly any difference.
" A silent massacre"---yes,I can just imagine everyone talking in whispers " don't shoot me ". The dogs weren't Basenji's either, which don't bark. What an idiot !
It certainly wasn't silent in Rob's Sheila scenario. More noise that Piccadilly Circus. But June, Daniel & Nicholas remained in bed sleeping.
Perhaps if you read JM's WS you might see where she says the dogs made a lot of noise whenever anyone approached the house. Are you saying she must be lying because they were not guard dogs and you have posted many times only guard dogs bark
I don't recall reading it in her WS. Or that Julie ever tried sneeking into WHF at 2am.
To me the dogs are a major problem to JB although I understand you cannot admit that Adam.Perhaps after you have read the Dickinson report you can read JM's WS and start catching up
Why would Julie mention the dogs in her WS? What page does she do this?
I cannot remember exactly where Adam, to be honest I don't take much notice of what she says, but if you are really stuck I will dig it out. Is it really surprising that dogs would kick up a racket when someone approaches the house it's quite common you know.
Look forward to reading it.
The dogs..18th November 1985: https://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,4952.0.html
