The drop / pendant earring...

[Adam]

As far as Crispy being a big enough deterrent to Bamber to stop him attempting the massacre, this is very unlikely - 

Crispy was not a guard dog.

Crispy may not have woken in the kitchen.

Crispy may have woken but not barked.

Crispy may have barked briefly before recognising Bamber.

It would be unlikely anyone awake upstairs behind closed doors would be able to hear Crispy bark.

There is no guarantee anyone upstairs would bother reacting to hearing a dog bark.

It would be impossible for Crispy's bark to wake people who are upstairs and asleep behind closed doors. 

[Adam]

The evidence is no one woke prior to receiving their first upstairs shots from Bamber.

So Crispy either did not bark, or barked but did not wake anyone.

[snow66!]

Can anybody see a phone under this stack of magazines?

Hard to say Dave,nothing obvious.Is that the pile where the phone was allegedly found?

[Rob_]

For supporters it would probably be better if Crispy slept in the main bedroom.

Barking continuously in the main bedroom would at least wake Nevill & June.

Crispy would of course need super dog hearing powers to hear through thick doors & walls.

Well if Bews and co could hear Crispy whining through thick walls from 30 yards on the outside, Crispy would have no trouble hearing someone approaching the house Adam.

Have you forgotten that dogs have much better hearing the humans?

[Rob_]

As far as Crispy being a big enough deterrent to Bamber to stop him attempting the massacre, this is very unlikely - 

Crispy was not a guard dog.

Crispy may not have woken in the kitchen.

Crispy may have woken but not barked.

Crispy may have barked briefly before recognising Bamber.

It would be unlikely anyone awake upstairs behind closed doors would be able to hear Crispy bark.

There is no guarantee anyone upstairs would bother reacting to hearing a dog bark.

It would be impossible for Crispy's bark to wake people who are upstairs and asleep behind closed doors.

Speak to a burglar Adam, the biggest deterrent is a dog, it does not have to be a guard dog as all dogs can bark 

Hint it's the noise they make.

[Adam]

Speak to a burglar Adam, the biggest deterrent is a dog, it does not have to be a guard dog as all dogs can bark 

Hint it's the noise they make.

You didn't address any of my 7 points.

Crispy was not a guard dog & Bamber was not a burglar to him.

[Adam]

As said, Bamber's first shots into each victim was without resistance -

June - 5 times in bed.

Nevill - Twice in the face from inches away.

Daniel - shot in bed.

Nicholas - shot in bed.

Sheila - shot under the chin.

----------

This confirms Crispy did not wake anyone.

[snow66!]

Dogs do have very good hearing as Rob says.Anyone who has ever owned one will confirm that they start barking and alert you that someone is approaching your property long before they knock on the door.

[Rob_]

You didn't address any of my 7 points.

Crispy was not a guard dog & Bamber was not a burglar to him.

When I was very young a friend had a tiny dog, when I went round to their house I would go via the back gate and despite knowing me very well the little dog would jump onto the window sill and bark the house down as soon as I went through the gate approx 40 yards away.

As for addressing your 7 points, do they need addressing?

[Rob_]

As far as Crispy being a big enough deterrent to Bamber to stop him attempting the massacre, this is very unlikely - 

Crispy was not a guard dog.

Crispy may not have woken in the kitchen.

Crispy may have woken but not barked.

Crispy may have barked briefly before recognising Bamber.

It would be unlikely anyone awake upstairs behind closed doors would be able to hear Crispy bark.

There is no guarantee anyone upstairs would bother reacting to hearing a dog bark.

It would be impossible for Crispy's bark to wake people who are upstairs and asleep behind closed doors.

Well I will address 1 of your points Adam, Crispy would have detected the fear in JB and his evil intentions, and probably fled upstairs barking.

[Rob_]

As said, Bamber's first shots into each victim was without resistance -

June - 5 times in bed.

Nevill - Twice in the face from inches away.

Daniel - shot in bed.

Nicholas - shot in bed.

Sheila - shot under the chin.

----------

This confirms Crispy did not wake anyone.

Because nobody clambered in through the window, otherwise Crispy would have done.

[Adam]

Dogs do have very good hearing as Rob says.Anyone who has ever owned one will confirm that they start barking and alert you that someone is approaching your property long before they knock on the door.

Well if Crispy did wake from Bamber's bathroom window entrance, the evidence is any long/short term barking did not wake anyone upstairs prior to Bamber opening fire.

[Rob_]

Well if Crispy did wake from Bamber's bathroom window entrance, the evidence is any long/short term barking did not wake anyone upstairs prior to Bamber opening fire.

Bamber would have had to nullify Crispy somehow before he committed the crime, he could not take the risk.

[Adam]

Crispy would be used to people constantly walking around WHF. Including at night.

At the time their were 5 people staying at WHF. Snow66! suggested Nevill had bladder problems & had to keep getting up at night.

Doubt that Crispy would bark whenever he saw someone. Dogs need sleep as well.

[Adam]

Bamber would have had to nullify Crispy somehow before he committed the crime, he could not take the risk.

If he did, it would be by letting Crispy know it was someone Crispy knew.