This is a wind up
Never have Jane or Caroline praised Adams contributions to the forum. It is a well established fact that no one has changed their minds by reading Adams posts. However you may be the first 
No, David. I don't believe it's a wind up but you are playing semantics.
You ARE correct in that I -and, off the top of my head, Caroline- have never lauded Adams threads per se, too many being too much, but I, and again, I believe, Caroline, as intelligent women, HAVE praised one or two points he's raised. For my own part, actually commenting that I'd previously been vociferous in my complaints about him but when I consider something worthy of praise I have the humility to offer it.