The logs state time of 03:26 and 03:36, Jeremy said he called his father back shortly after he called him which he said was at 03:10. So what happened to the time in between?
This is the line the supporters often try to use:
Nevill phones Jeremy at 3:10 call last maybe a minute after Jeremy answered so it is 3:11-3:12 at the latest when it ends
3:11-3:12 Upon hanging up Nevill phones police and speaks to police for a least 5 minutes
3:11-3:12 Jeremy phones Nevill but the line is busy because he is speaking to police
3:13-3:25 Jeremy looks up the phone number of the Witham police station and dials but gets no answer so then looks up the Chelmsford station.
3:26 Jeremy phones Chelmsford.
What this scenario ignores is that this would require the call to Julie to be well after all the roomates say the call came- they said no later than 3:30 and most said much earlier than that.
Also, it is bad enough for Jeremy to take the time to look up Witham instead of dialing 999. After that failed why would he look up another station that might be unattended? Why not dial 999 at that point? In the meantime Witham was not unattended. His excuse for not dialing 999 made no sense. He said he didn't think it police repsonse would be any faster but if he waste over 10 minutes looking up phone numbers instead of dialing 999 then clearly that clearly impacts police response time.
If he didn't phone police until 3:36 then clearly that messes up things far more because the gap between when Nevill allegedly hung up the phone and Jeremy called police would be significantly greater. But 9 minutes from then would mean Jeremy did not get off the phone with police until 3:45 and that he sped his ass off only to slow down like as snail the last mile. 3:36 is probably when the call ended and Jeremy supporters are much better off with making that argument than Jeremy calling at 3:36.
None of this helps suggest a call from Nevill though. Jeremy claimin ghe got a busy signal doesn't even prove he actually tried to call WHF. His conviction included him leaving the phone off the hook before he left so he would not even need to call to know the phone would get a busy signal. But if he did call naturally he would get a busy signal. The phone off the hook explains such so arguing that because Jeremy claims he got a busy signal that means the busy signal was because Nevill phoned police is fallacy.
The most important questions to ask those who think Nevill phoned police are:
1) why would West and Bonnett have not dispatched a car in response to Nevill's call? The police were clearly called to respond on the basis of Jeremy's call not a call from anyone else.
2) Why would West ask Jeremy for information he already would have gotten from Nevill? West clearly asked Jeremy for Sheila's name, age, the address and phone number of WHF, who was at WHF and other questions that Nevill alreayd would have answered. Why would West ask such instead of telling Jeremy he already knew about the situation because he already spoke to Nevill?
Those who suggest Nevill called have to answer these questions and if they have no plausible answer then they have no reasonable way to suggest their position is plausible.
