Murders at White House Farm by Carol Ann Lee.

[Lucy522]

He was wearing PJ's

I know but we have no pictures of them or the front of them

[susan]

I agree it was probably very one sided whoever fought Nevil. JB didn't have any defensive injuries.  I cannot believe Sheila would stand a chance against Nevil even if psychotic because of his height and reach although she was reasonably tall she was very slight but if he was badly injured she would have had the advantage and it changes everything imo.

Hi Maggie

I agree with your post whoever battered poor Nevil would have had to do it when Nevil was so badly injured he could not fight back he was a big strong man and would have defended himself.  Just a thought if Jeremy had murdered his family would he have been so stupid as to make up the story of the phone call he would have thought maybe the phones could be tested and it would have been obvious he was lying.  IMO had he committed the murders he would have gone home to bed gone to work next morning and discover the horrendous scene on his arrival.

[Steve_uk]

Hi Maggie

I agree with your post whoever battered poor Nevil would have had to do it when Nevil was so badly injured he could not fight back he was a big strong man and would have defended himself.  Just a thought if Jeremy had murdered his family would he have been so stupid as to make up the story of the phone call he would have thought maybe the phones could be tested and it would have been obvious he was lying.  IMO had he committed the murders he would have gone home to bed gone to work next morning and discover the horrendous scene on his arrival.

He probably did telephone his answerphone at Bourtree Cottage from White House Farm and rushed back to destroy the tape, which of course would not have had Nevill's voice on it. It was possible Jeremy was hoping that the blue telephone would have recorded the last number dialled as proof, but one of the Police used the telephone that first morning erasing that facility from memory.

[Caroline]

I know but we have no pictures of them or the front of them

I saw a picture of Nevill some years back. Not nice!

[Lucy522]

Hi Maggie

I agree with your post whoever battered poor Nevil would have had to do it when Nevil was so badly injured he could not fight back he was a big strong man and would have defended himself.  Just a thought if Jeremy had murdered his family would he have been so stupid as to make up the story of the phone call he would have thought maybe the phones could be tested and it would have been obvious he was lying.  IMO had he committed the murders he would have gone home to bed gone to work next morning and discover the horrendous scene on his arrival.

This is my thought Susan why not leave it to the morning it wouldn't of took long for someone to find

[Caroline]

This is my thought Susan why not leave it to the morning it wouldn't of took long for someone to find

He wanted to have the police think he was elsewhere, if he was home answering a call from his dad - he couldn't be at WHF killing them. The call was his alibi.

[Lucy522]

He wanted to have the police think he was elsewhere, if he was home answering a call from his dad - he couldn't be at WHF killing them. The call was his alibi.

Not really because it couldn't be known if it happened or not

[Adam]

I know baloney when I read it, and I've had enough for one day.

Good day to you!

Bit disappointed TomG didn't address my scenario or give me his scenario I requested. Considering he said supporters don't put in much effort.

Saying Bamber is innocent because Nevill's first two face shots didn't kill him isn't exactly exerting himself.

[maggie]

I saw a picture of Nevill some years back. Not nice!

I'm sure it wasn't, I tried not to picture anything when I posted abut his injuries, I'm thankful there are no photos on here.  I find the photos of June bad enough and I'm sure they are easy to look at compared to Nevill.

[Jane]

Not really because it couldn't be known if it happened or not

But they DID accept that he was at home in Goldhanger when he called to tell them about the alleged call from Nevill. Had he not done, he'd have had no way of proving where he was the previous night.

[Adam]

Hi Maggie

I agree with your post whoever battered poor Nevil would have had to do it when Nevil was so badly injured he could not fight back he was a big strong man and would have defended himself.  Just a thought if Jeremy had murdered his family would he have been so stupid as to make up the story of the phone call he would have thought maybe the phones could be tested and it would have been obvious he was lying.  IMO had he committed the murders he would have gone home to bed gone to work next morning and discover the horrendous scene on his arrival.

If Nevill couldn't fight back he wouldn't have got downstairs and been brutally beaten.

Bamber was there to execute everyone. Not waste time beating up people who couldn't fight back.

[Lucy522]

Has anyone ever thought he paid someone to commit the massacre

[Jane]

Has anyone ever thought he paid someone to commit the massacre

He told Julie he'd paid Malcolm Mcdonald £2000 to do it.

[Lucy522]

He told Julie he'd paid Malcolm Mcdonald £2000 to do it.

I had a discussion with my dad the other night, one of the scenarios we came up with was this could of been the case and a gun was held to Neville head and he was made to call Jeremy leaving the trail of calls

[Adam]

Has anyone ever thought he paid someone to commit the massacre

Err. Yes there are threads. Does it not say this in the books you have read ?

Mike suggested an SAS style hit man team killed everyone.

My thread yesterday asked if it was a hit woman as Bamber told the police after his arrest Nevill may have said "She" rather than "Sheila".