New book ?

[guest154]

Jeremy sent me the same logs, the only things edited are spelling mistakes.

I use to cringe that you'd messaged Bamber (sorry!  ) but now I think it actually turned out to be a good thing because imagine how much rubbish people would get away with if you hadn't have gotten such information straight from Bamber.

Maybe they doubt the source. 

[Caroline]

The copy she said she had was altered and edited . Edited normally means bits taken out . Not quite the same as a spelling mistake ?  Perhaps it's not the same part of the log?

Jeremy said they were edited to me too - they just have spelling mistakes on some but not on others. Of course I havent seen what Poppy is talking about it but I very uch doubt we are talking about different logs being 'edited'.

[Caroline]

I use to cringe that you'd messaged Bamber (sorry!  ) but now I think it actually turned out to be a good thing because imagine how much rubbish people would get away with if you hadn't have gotten such information straight from Bamber.

Maybe they doubt the source. 

  - well, as long as it's something I asked, I know I can sort the wheat from the chaff for my own peice of mind.

[Caroline]

If Poppy was to release a book on the case... it would be the worst of an already bad bunch. Her blog is often cited as a source for some of the biggest mis-truths in the case.



Or perhaps the notorious Poppy is being economical with the truth.

Have to agree with this!

[Jan]

And why is that funny , logs have carbon copies for a reason. So do you know the originals and not photocopies have been seen?

[Jan]

the original radio and telephone messages log and incident report. All are still being withheld from the defence. On every occasion on which the defence team has asked for them, Essex constabulary has refused to provide them. I put it directly to the Minister—and ask her to respond—that that is surely an intolerable state of affairs.




This is a quote from a thread on this forum.

[Jan]

If Poppy was to release a book on the case... it would be the worst of an already bad bunch. Her blog is often cited as a source for some of the biggest mis-truths in the case.



Or perhaps the notorious Poppy is being economical with the truth.

Don't know her , so could not possibly comment on that .

[sami]

the original radio and telephone messages log and incident report. All are still being withheld from the defence. On every occasion on which the defence team has asked for them, Essex constabulary has refused to provide them. I put it directly to the Minister—and ask her to respond—that that is surely an intolerable state of affairs.




This is a quote from a thread on this forum.

did the minister reply 

[Caroline]

the original radio and telephone messages log and incident report. All are still being withheld from the defence. On every occasion on which the defence team has asked for them, Essex constabulary has refused to provide them. I put it directly to the Minister—and ask her to respond—that that is surely an intolerable state of affairs.




This is a quote from a thread on this forum.

By who?

[Jan]

What does it matter ? All I was saying was that the information I had seen was that the original logs with carbon copies had not been disclosed . If someone knows better then show me. You know me I only post what I believe to be true and will accept if I am wrong. Is Sami thinks they have then she can show me the evidence . Or explain what is so amusing?

[Caroline]

What does it matter ? All I was saying was that the information I had seen was that the original logs with carbon copies had not been disclosed . If someone knows better then show me. You know me I only post what I believe to be true and will accept if I am wrong. Is Sami thinks they have then she can show me the evidence . Or explain what is so amusing?

It doesn't matter but if something is quoted, I just like to know who by - in this case it was Andrew Hunter. I can only tell you that Jeremy told me (and CAL) that he now has 'almost' all of the documents and pictures held by EP. The number of things claimed to be still hidden is (in my opinion) overly exaggerated.

[guest154]

Don't know her , so could not possibly comment on that .

Read some of her blog when you get chance.

[sami]

What does it matter ? All I was saying was that the information I had seen was that the original logs with carbon copies had not been disclosed . If someone knows better then show me. You know me I only post what I believe to be true and will accept if I am wrong. Is Sami thinks they have then she can show me the evidence . Or explain what is so amusing?

dont take offence jan,i just get the giggles now and than oh before i forget iam a fella not a woman

[sami]

Not getting involved that thank you.


As far as remember only copies of the logs have ever been seen as  EP have never released the originals

if there are copies are of the originals they should say the same things

[Caroline]

dont take offence jan,i just get the giggles now and than oh before i forget iam a fella not a woman

Wasn't sure who Jan was replying to so I replied as well