My argument was that as families,the Boutflours didn't know the Bambers,or what went on within those walls at WHF,so therefore would not have been aware of the severity of Sheila's illness or what it entailed. Yet they spouted chapter and verse about two siblings who they didn't know and people believed them ?
They were close enough to know Sheila never fired any weapons and had no interest in guns. They also knew she was never violent even when she had episodes when she stopped taking her medicaiton.
They were close enough to know Jeremy flat out lied about her having fired the murder weapon and all other guns in the house and lied about the gun not fitting int he closet with the scope and moderator attached.
You profess to know more about Jeremy's character than the family though you never even met him.
We know Sheila's only episodes were prior to starting treatment and when she stopped taking her medication.
We know she was being injected for this very reason and thus could no longer avoid taking her medication.
We know that even when she stopped taking her medication she wasn't violent towards others during any of the episodes.
We know the episodes were brought on by something she didn't simply wake up in the middle of the night and have an episode- she was interacting with people when the episodes were brought on.
So the picture you try to paint fails miserably. You, Alias and others choose to ignore the evidence to pretend she was likely to have an episode in the middle of the night, that she was likely to murder them all by shooting them during an episode.
But this inquiry is all not even important for us because we care about the actual evidence at the scene. That is what proves who the murderer was. State of mind makes no difference at all.
It is not possible for Sheila to have loaded the gun, to have shot everyone including herself and to have beaten Nevill without getting GSR/soot and blood from the victims (particularly Nevill during the beating) on her clothes and body. It is not possibly for her to have inflicted the beating on Nevill without there being some injuries to her hands and nails and bare feet yet there was none. The only way to avoid such damage to her hands would be if she wore gloves but such gloves would have been found at the scene if she wore any.
The killer started the attack in the master bedroom firing 10 shots into June and Nevill. There was no phone in that room because Jeremy removed it. There was no way Nevill could have phoned anyone before the shooting commenced. After the shooting commenced he couldn't speak because of his injuries. There is no way he could have phoned anyone let alone Jeremy.
Sheila can't have killed herself because:
1) she didn't load the weapon
2) she never fired the gun at all
3) she was seated when shot and after she was dead she was moved flat by someone else who then placed the gun on top of her
4) she was shot with the moderator attached so could not have reached the trigger to shoot herself and after her death she most certainly didn't remove the moderator and put it in the closet
5) after she died and her body was moved flat a pool of blood formed on the floor and the Bible was placed in this pool while the blood was still wet. Clearly she didn't do this herself the killer did.
All of these things prove it is impossible for Sheila to have been the killer but rather someone tried to frame her for the killings. State of mind is irrelevant to this evidence it makes no difference at all even if Sheila had been violent in the past during episodes it would not make it possible for her to be the killer.
