What Makes Supporters Believe Jeremy is Innocent?

[scipio_usmc]

Sheila may have intended to kill the whole family and demanded that Neville called Jeremy.

Why would Nevill comply though and tell Jeremy to come be killed? 

[susan]

Scipio I agree with your point had Sheila intended to kill Ralph and June and the twins Ralph would not have complied with her request what would be the point.

[scipio_usmc]

I doubt Neville could have said much more than he did,with a gun pointing at him. One wrong move and all that---------------------

All Sheila would have to do is wait for a time when the entire family is around and attack at that point as opposed to waiting for a time when Jeremy is not there and hoping Nevill would be willing to call him over to be executed.

It makes no sense for Nevill to comply and no sense for June to be in bed as this is going on.  Nor does it make sense to march him back to the master bedroom to kill both parents the same time.  It would be easier to kill him right after he finished the phone call, to reload and then go upstairs to go after June and the boys.   

[Jan]

Makes you wonder if JM used the hit man story as there was no explanation about the disposal or cleaning of his clothes/shoes/gloves.

[scipio_usmc]

Makes you wonder if JM used the hit man story as there was no explanation about the disposal or cleaning of his clothes/shoes/gloves.

He had a month to dispose of evidence.  There is no way at all to suggest there was no explanation for his ability to have disposed of evidence.

[David1819]

The denial on here never ceases to amaze.  Every scrap of evidence points to an innocent Sheila and a guilty Jeremy but hey, let's not worry too much about the facts and the evidence as a good conspiracy theory is always worth a punt.



It wasn't me guv...honest!

So covering his face make him a mass murderer 

[maggie]

OK, thank-you for that. Can you please explain why Maxine Carr, girl friend to Ian Huntley, was also charged with the same thing when she wasn't just not in the house when the murders occurred, she wasn't even in the COUNTY. I can understand WHY she gave him an alibi. What woman would want to think her fella capable of SUCH a heinous act? But, unlike Jeremy, he'd never given her a clue about his dark thoughts. I guess you'll say that there's a point of law here somewhere but all I see is Julie, who'd known about Jeremy's plans for a year -albeit, she may not have believed he'd go through with it- and vouched for him despite saying she KNEW what he'd done, and Maxine, who had no inkling what HER man had done but believed what he'd told her and gave him an alibi on the strength of it. Julie walks free to, what was then, a small fortune and Maxine gets a lengthy prison sentence. There really is no wonder that we Brits remain suspicious of out judicial system.

I do agree, have always thought Maxine Carr was treated really badly.

[scipio_usmc]

I do agree, have always thought Maxine Carr was treated really badly.

She was prosecuted because she thwarted the investigation with a false alibi and wanted to not only punish her but also to send a message to others that they better not do that or they too will risk jail.

[Adam]

Makes you wonder if JM used the hit man story as there was no explanation about the disposal or cleaning of his clothes/shoes/gloves.

I have suggested closure on this issue in a thread. You must learn to close issues.

[Jan]

It is her own words that trip her up . On the night - she "knew" he had done it.

And even when he was planning there was a possibility she was not sure he would carry it out - and then in another sentence she said she did know he meant it - contradiction.

But she had the opportunity when with the police on her own at the mortuary to tell them everything and get him caught immediately - and because she did not - and the fact that the moderator might not have been found makes it obvious that she DID pervert the course of justice. If he is guilty then he nearly got away with it because of her.

[Adam]

The denial on here never ceases to amaze.  Every scrap of evidence points to an innocent Sheila and a guilty Jeremy but hey, let's not worry too much about the facts and the evidence as a good conspiracy theory is always worth a punt.



It wasn't me guv...honest!

 :D

[Jan]

I have suggested closure on this issue in a thread. You must learn to close issues.

Adam it takes a lot to get me cross - but I will be getting personal and rude with you very shortly if you don't stop with your personal and sarcastic posts. This is a warning because I don't want to give you reason to run off to the moderators.

[lookout]

I have suggested closure on this issue in a thread. You must learn to close issues.

Just because YOU say so ?

[lookout]

I have suggested closure on this issue in a thread. You must learn to close issues.

It's all your threads that need closing.How do you feel about that ?
Just because you didn't start it ? Get a grip.

[Adam]

Everyone must learn to close issues.

I had an open mind about the rumoured lockable from outside window. However after further investigation I found 15 sources that it could be locked from outside.

My mind is now closed on this issue.