Why Would Essex Police Not Mention The Fact That Neville Called The Police?

[Caroline]

The difference in wording on the two logs is a bit odd. Can´t see a reason for the "interpretation" into "my daughter" and "my gun".

It depends how West relayed the call to Bonnet.

[Caroline]

All emergency calls are recorded,Caroline.Even today,as a matter of course because of situations like this happening.

But it wasn't an emergency call, he just called the station number - there was no 999 call.

[nugnug]

i doubt if you get the word sister mixed up with the word daughter.

[Caroline]

So if Neville didn't make the call,how did Jeremy get to Goldhanger in 10 minutes ? On what mode of transport ? Then brace himself as though nothing had happened,to phone the police from his own home ?

That's the point, there was no second call.

[JackiePreece]

That's the point, there was no second call.

You have no way of knowing that !!!

[nugnug]

so if there was no second call then a gun would of hade to have become my gun and sister would of had to have turned into daughter.

thats a fair bit to get mixed up.

[Alias]

It depends how West relayed the call to Bonnet.

Nevill would not have said to Jeremy "my daughter" - it is the "my" that is weird, and I cannot see how that came about. How did that happen in a policeman´s brain?

[nugnug]

and jeremy wouldent of called them and said my daughter.

[Caroline]

Nevill would not have said to Jeremy "my daughter" - it is the "my" that is weird, and I cannot see how that came about. How did that happen in a policeman´s brain?

I know he wouldn't, that's not what I meant. When Jeremy called the police, West took down what he said (father called, Sheila's got the gun etc.). However, West then relayed the details to Bonnet and must have said a Mr Bamber from WHF called and said his daughter has one of his guns etc. So that's what Bonnet wrote. The Neville call had never been hidden from anyone, the jury saw it and Bonnet explain that he wrote what West told him. I could understand the suspicion if it was the Neville log that the jury didn't see but it wasn't.

[Caroline]

You have no way of knowing that !!!

OK fair enough, I can't say 100% that Neville didn't call but I'm 99.9% certain in my own mind.

[nugnug]

I know he wouldn't, that's not what I meant. When Jeremy called the police, West took down what he said (father called, Sheila's got the gun etc.). However, West then relayed the details to Bonnet and must have said a Mr Bamber from WHF called and said his daughter has one of his guns etc. So that's what Bonnet wrote. The Neville call had never been hidden from anyone, the jury saw it and Bonnet explain that he wrote what West told him. I could understand the suspicion if it was the Neville log that the jury didn't see but it wasn't.

im being a bt pedantic here but nevile dident say my daughter to Jeremy or my gun he said your sister and a gun.

[susan]

Caroline on that note nobody can say one hundred percent Neville did phone

[nugnug]

well of course they cant.

[Caroline]

im being a bt pedantic here but nevile dident say my daughter to Jeremy or my gun he said your sister and a gun.

I'm not talking about what he said to Jeremy - I'm talking about what was said to the police.

[nugnug]

bt if thats what said nevile said to him then how did it turn into my daughter when jeremys words were that his father had said your sister.

how does your sister turn into my daughter.