"As previously stated, NATO are still planning and arming for 20th century wars(Aircraft carriers and air power). All neutralised by modern air defence, missile tech and electronic warfare. In any openly declared NATO/Russia war (or China, Iran and others) no aircraft carrier or naval strike group would survive the opening skirmishes."
Above my post from Jan 2024 reposted by David earlier in the thread alongside a clown face. Below, further discussion on the subject from June last year for you, David.
gringo-
Iran have many options in closing the Strait of Hormuz that no amount of warships could prevent, David, not to mention that in a gloves off conflict, warships will be amongst the first targets at such close range. Warships in all out gloves off WW3 will be as effective as Cavalry would have been in WW2. As artillery and tanks rendered cavalry obsolete, warships have also met their moment of obsolescence. Anti ship missiles and drones are to warships as artillery/tanks were to cavalry.
David-
There is no way they can block off the straight and hold off the USN. They have no peer adversary.
Warships have existed for thousands of years and I expect they will continue to evolve for perhaps a thousand more.
gringo-
You are at odds with US intel and all interested parties in that view, David. Iran are unlikely to do so but the capability to close it isn't really disputed. I expect naval power will evolve in some ways, probably some form of unmanned drones, but Aircraft Carrier strike groups are already becoming neutralised...
It is generally accepted, even by US intel, that Iran could close the Strait. It is a card that Iran holds that impacts on all other decisions in the attempts to subdue Iran.
US navy couldn't prevent the closure, David. Iran don't need to be a "peer adversary" in naval power to close Strait of Hormuz.David-
There is no way a green water navy defeats a blue water navy. Its not even debatable.
Naval defences are adapting to new threats
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lJROWdRN7N0According to Claude -...As of June 2025, the Strait has never been closed during Middle East conflicts, and
in the face of a determined US response, Iran is not capable of completely closing the strait. Fast forward to today;
https://x.com/RealPepeEscobar/status/2028757660766699929"Hormuz is closed. But NOT for Russian and Chinese vessels.
Only Western tankers have to fight a floating traffic jam off Fujairah and Khor Fakkan."