Flaws in BuboBubo's Sheila Scenario.

[Adam]

Will make a start now.

https://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,11892.0.html

[Adam]

I have done the same with Rob, ILB, David and Snow66!

My watertight scenario has been available for people to comment on for years. 

[Adam]

I will start at the 'What happened between 09.30 pm 06/08/85 and 07.30 am 07/08/85' part.

The earlier stuff is just waffle.

[Adam]

Quickest way to do it is to list the invented things.

Together with listing the things that do match the crime scene evidence.

[Adam]

Invented:

SC had a few words before going upstairs to sulk.

June was tired and when NB returned they had a discussion about SC and the best course of future action.

SC returned to the kitchen behaving as if she was starting a psychotic episode.

She flew at June and they had a physical fight.

SC went and locked herself in the downstairs toilet.

NB got up to visit the bathroom for a pee.

SC started to make threats towards her parents who quickly moved to a position by June’s wardrobe.

NB said to June that JB should be arriving in about ten minutes.

went downstairs to open the door in preparation for JB’s arrival.

SC had knocked June to the floor.

June remained vigilant while in the box room.

(June) with the shot gun partly raised in a firing position, she was confronted by the TFG

Meanwhile June had recovered partially and made her way slowly down the back stairs.

So she retired to her room lay on the bed and shot herself with one shot under the chin.

[Adam]

Not matching crime scene evidence.

She flew at June and they had a physical fight.

NB managed to separate them but not before both he and June had sustained minor cuts and bruises.

NB picked up the bedroom phone and phoned JB.

NB said to June that JB should be arriving in about ten minutes.

went downstairs to open the door in preparation for JB’s arrival . 😯

phoned the police from the downstairs phone

SC had knocked June to the floor.

June remained vigilant while in the box room.

(June) with the shot gun partly raised in a firing position, she was confronted by the TFG.

He had eventually ended up against the Aga.

Meanwhile June had recovered partially and made her way slowly down the back stairs.

So she retired to her room lay on the bed and shot herself with one shot under the chin

[Adam]

NB and June went to bed.

----------

I actually agree that happened!

[Adam]

Would not happen.

SC started to make threats towards her parents who quickly moved to a position by June’s wardrobe.

----------

A fully fit June and Nevill would instantly remove the rifle.



NB confronted Sheila.

--------

Still fully fit he would have regained the rifle. Not run away.


When she reached the kitchen she threw herself at SC who was beating NB

----------

Sheila would not beat a now lifeless Nevill.

[Adam]

Well there has been no shots fired yet.

So far 9 invented things have happened, Sheila did this, June said that etc.

Together with 5 things that do not match the crime scene and one thing that would not happen.

There needs to be none of each.

[Adam]

Some invented situations also do not match the crime scene!

[Adam]

Lets not forget the one thing that did happen - Nevill and June went to bed.

Will continue later today.

[Roch]

Not matching crime scene evidence.

She flew at June and they had a physical fight.

From the following article: https://empowerinnocent.wixsite.com/ccrcwatch/post/exploring-the-white-house-farm-murders-and-additional-injuries-to-the-adult-victims-not-disclosed-at

[Adam]

attacked him with the rifle beating him with both ends of the rifle.

----------

I agree that happened as well. Nevill still hasn't laid a glove on her.

[Bubo bubo]

attacked him with the rifle beating him with both ends of the rifle.

----------

I agree that happened as well. Nevill still hasn't laid a glove on her.

He had received 5 gunshot wounds by that time and was in no position to retaliate

[Adam]

I agree Nevill did not speak to the police. Disagee he would ring them.