Sequence of events surrounding the silencer.

[David1819]

There you go again. Refusing to answer questions. On your own scenario!

Exactly how the Gish Gallop works. 

[Adam]

David didn't complain on this thread when I first asked questions.

He just didn't answer as he had no answer. Then hoped I would not chase him up.

When I did chase him up he still refused.

Not to worry. It's only 37 obstacles to his AE scenario he probably spent days trying to work out.

[David1819]

Exactly how the Gish Gallop works. 

How to debate the case like Adam.

Make a list of bullshit so long its not reasonable for anyone to answer it. Claim victory when nobody answers it (as intended). Should someone answer - copy and paste the list again pretending nobody answered it. 

[Adam]

AE must be really worried.

David has his scenario. And it only has 37 holes.

[David1819]

AE must be really worried.

David has his scenario. And it only has 37 holes.

She can sleep well at night after reading your "37 holes" I am sure.   

[Adam]

How to debate the case like Adam.

Make a list of bullshit so long its not reasonable for anyone to answer it. Claim victory when nobody answers it (as intended). Should someone answer - copy and paste the list again pretending nobody answered it. 

Yes no other supporters answered.

So it was down to you. To support your own scenario!

You should do what the OS does. Create a Youtube video. Then switch off the 'comments' section.

[David1819]

Its a pity Adam only recently found these "37 holes". Ten years ago AE could have sued the hell out of the Telegraph, The producers of Behind Mansion Walls, CTSB and Peter Sutherhurst for libel thanks to those "37 holes".

Slamdunk!   

[David1819]

Any reasonable questions about my scenario will be answered. Trolling will either be called out for what it is or ignored.

[Adam]

Ann Eaton takes Julie to the mortuary and notes down Nevills injuries after talking to Julie.

----------

How would Julie know about Nevill's injuries. She would just see the faces.

[Adam]

After visiting the accountant, Jeremy asks Ann Eaton to pay back the loan for the farmland that she is living on. In order to pay death duties.

---------

Any proof of that?

[Adam]

While there she would have seen the blue coat obscuring a certain area of the mantle shelf.

----------

Any proof of that?

[Adam]

Relatives visit WHF again and collected the silencer and also take back home Sheila's blood stained clothing. David Boutflour does not recall seeing any blood, paint or hair on the silencer while at WHF at this.

---------

I assume these are in AE's & DB's WS's.

[David1819]

Ann Eaton takes Julie to the mortuary and notes down Nevills injuries after talking to Julie.

----------

How would Julie know about Nevill's injuries. She would just see the faces.

Nevills face is mentioned in her notes. Along with what DC Clarke told her, that's all she needed to know iy order to make it look like the silencer was involved in the kitchen altercation.

[Adam]

AE would need to know -

Is Bamber innocent.

Sheila's arm lenght.

The rifle lenght with silencer.

Could Sheila have shot herself with the silencer attached.

What back splatter is.

Who of the 5 deceased received contact shots.

What locations would contact shots need to be to produce back splatter.

Where were the contact shots on the 5 deceased.

Is there any other forensic evidence against Sheila.

Was there a silencer next to Sheila.

How to realistically put blood into a silencer.

Where was Sheila's blood to insert into a silencer.

Did the rifle barrell already have blood on/in.

Did the crime scene photos show an unscratched aga.

How to realistically scratch the aga.

Had the police already checked all silencers at WHF.

The chance of this one piece of framed evidence getting a conviction.

The punishment if caught doing this.

Confidence the other relatives that none would succumb to police pressure.

Sheila's blood group.

The blood group of each other.

----------

This had to be found out very quickly. Providing AE had the idea & decided to go ahead.

David can also address these obstacles AE would have.

Twenty eighth request. 

[Adam]

The underwear was first mentioned in the housekeepers statement. And it also relates to the blood found on the kitchen.

----------

How?