You'd have had SJ to thank if we'd still have had the death penalty,with his gut-instinct !
So would you as you you believe in it. Interesting, isn't it? Two people. Two opposing "gut instincts". Which one is correct? Who would we put money on? A man with years of experience and training in what to look out for, who has had the benefit of meeting and speaking with the suspect, OR a woman with no experience, but an ego so big she thinks she know better than the experts, and makes a judgement call from a photo? Mmm. Difficult one.